I worry that it is unfair on judges for me to select a small part of a carefully crafted judgment for discussion. However comments on practice and procedure are clearly made, within a judgment, for a reason. So I want to point out short observation of Mr Justice Dingeman in his judgment yeste...
I wonder what solicitors actually get paid for and how many understand how to properly instruct and prepare their own counsel. Far too many firms get a junior to photocopy a mountain of paper and shove it in bundles with no understanding at all of what they are doing. Well prepped bundles are a great tactical advantage. Annoying the judge immensely a couple of weeks before he sees the case is madness. Needless to say; when as an unrepresented litigant with no legal training I appeared (successfully) at the CA my bundles were immaculate 😉
I tend to think that, if the only complaint Dingemans could come up was that “I” looks like “1”, he was a very lucky judge. Judges should remember that litigants are hoping for justice and are not there to listen to well-paid judges moaning about the numbering/lettering of bundles.
The truth of this matter is that most of the judges who complain about bundles will have appeared as counsel in many cases in which the bundles were less than perfect (or contained reams of material which was never referred to at trial).
Tim, see the response above. A litigant in person presents bundles that are “immaculate”. The reason bundles have such a high profile on this blog is because they can save (or waste) court time. It was a perfectly proper observation. The fact that bad practice occurred in the past cannot be a justification for not trying to improve things.
Yes Tim. That is obviously because bundles are prepared by solicitors not barristers.
Gordon maybe you could do a blog highlighting the Supreme Court bundling service thingy. Available for electronic filing in courts which allow or printing otherwise for normal service in all courts. Judges seem to love it. You could even carry an add of theirs and earn a few shekels to eke out your meagre pay at the bar. 😉