This blog has looked many times at cases which consider the practical implication of the test in Central Manchester Health Authority v W (A minor) [1998] PIQR P324: the inferences a trial judge should infer when witnesses are noted called at trial. This issue was considered by His Honour Judge Butle...
I had a quick read of the judgment, and find it difficult to believe that so much effort – and valuable court time – has been wasted on such a pathetic claim that resulted in damages amounting to the grand total of £476.18.
It’s absurd that scarce court resources can be squandered on this type of nonsense that only benefits the lawyers concerned. In view of the triviality of the sum awarded there should have been no order for costs, so as to discourage similarly ridiculous claims in the future.