Civil Litigation Brief ®
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Membership Plans
  • Webinars
  • Login
Updates and Commentary on Civil Procedure, by Gordon Exall, Barrister, Kings Chambers
Browse: Home » Appeals » Page 2
LATE WITNESS STATEMENTS, RELIEF FROM SANCTIONS (OR NOT...) AND THE COURT OF APPEAL CONSIDERS "WHAT IS A TRIAL?": THE DEFINITION PROVES TO BE VERY IMPORTANT FOR THIS APPELLANT...

LATE WITNESS STATEMENTS, RELIEF FROM SANCTIONS (OR NOT…) AND THE COURT OF APPEAL CONSIDERS “WHAT IS A TRIAL?”: THE DEFINITION PROVES TO BE VERY IMPORTANT FOR THIS APPELLANT…

July 24, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions

One of the key factors in this Court of Appeal judgment was the meaning of the word “trial”.  Curiously this is not defined in the rules and has only been considered in two previous cases.    The issue was important…

WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: A JUDGE IS NOT BOUND TO ACCEPT ALL DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: THE CLAIMANT "HONESTLY BELIEVED" THE CASE BUT THIS DID NOT PROVE IT...

WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: A JUDGE IS NOT BOUND TO ACCEPT ALL DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE: THE CLAIMANT “HONESTLY BELIEVED” THE CASE BUT THIS DID NOT PROVE IT…

July 22, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

We are looking at a case where an unsuccessful claimant attempted to argue that the trial judge had got the facts wrong, in particular there was a failure to take account of documentary evidence.   This judgment highlights the difficulties of…

"STING OPERATIONS", SECRET AGENTS,  NAIVE SOLICITORS DISCLOSING THEIR CLIENT'S PRIVILEGED INFORMATION, STRIKING OUT AND ABUSE OF PROCESS: COURT OF APPEAL DECISION HIGHLIGHTS THE MAJOR RISKS OF "PRIVILEGE HUNTING"

“STING OPERATIONS”, SECRET AGENTS, NAIVE SOLICITORS DISCLOSING THEIR CLIENT’S PRIVILEGED INFORMATION, STRIKING OUT AND ABUSE OF PROCESS: COURT OF APPEAL DECISION HIGHLIGHTS THE MAJOR RISKS OF “PRIVILEGE HUNTING”

July 22, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Members Content, Striking out

Here the Court of Appeal looks at one of the most remarkable issues of “litigation conduct” that has occurred in recent years. The claimants hired a “black ops” operative to befriend and obtain privileged and confidential information from the defendants’…

THROWBACK FRIDAY: ANOTHER (YES ANOTHER) CASE WHERE A LITIGANT ARGUED "MY CASE WAS SO HOPELESS I SHOULDN'T HAVE TO PAY YOUR COSTS" (OCTOBER 2024)

THROWBACK FRIDAY: ANOTHER (YES ANOTHER) CASE WHERE A LITIGANT ARGUED “MY CASE WAS SO HOPELESS I SHOULDN’T HAVE TO PAY YOUR COSTS” (OCTOBER 2024)

July 17, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Costs, Members Content

This week we have been looking at could broadly be called “ambitious” arguments by, or on behalf of,  litigants as to why they should not pay costs.  There are a surprising number of such cases. Here we revisit a post…

CIVIL PROCEDURE, OPAQUE EVIDENCE AND "YOU SHOULD HAVE KNOWN": ARGUMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN REJECTED BY THE COURTS - TWO EXAMPLES AND THE UNHAPPY CONSEQUENCES FOR THE LITIGANTS...

CIVIL PROCEDURE, OPAQUE EVIDENCE AND “YOU SHOULD HAVE KNOWN”: ARGUMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN REJECTED BY THE COURTS – TWO EXAMPLES AND THE UNHAPPY CONSEQUENCES FOR THE LITIGANTS…

July 15, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Members Content

We are looking at an argument deployed in a case we considered earlier today. It was an argument that the defendants should have been able to “divine” from the oblique nature of the claimant’s evidence that funding was not in…

CAN THE COURT REFUSE TO ISSUE A CLAIM FORM? CAN THE STAFF LAWFULLY REFER THE ISSUE TO THE JUDGE? AN UNUSUAL APPLICATION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW

CAN THE COURT REFUSE TO ISSUE A CLAIM FORM? CAN THE STAFF LAWFULLY REFER THE ISSUE TO THE JUDGE? AN UNUSUAL APPLICATION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW

July 14, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Uncategorized

Here we look at an unusual application for judicial review. It is all about the powers of the County Court to refer matters, upon issue, to the judge for consider.  It makes clear that court staff have no power to…

HALLUCINATED CASE LAW AND THE CROWN PROSECUTION SERVICE (OF ALL BODIES...)

HALLUCINATED CASE LAW AND THE CROWN PROSECUTION SERVICE (OF ALL BODIES…)

July 13, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Artificial Intelligence, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content

All cases of hallucinated cases are serious, however some may be more serious than others. If we have a situation where the Crown Prosecution Service files documents which rely on cases that simply do not exist, this has to be…

MAZUR MATTERS 64: THE COURT REJECTS WOULD BE APPELLANT'S ARGUMENT THAT A CLAIMANT'S REPRESENTATIVE HAD NO RIGHT OF AUDIENCE

MAZUR MATTERS 64: THE COURT REJECTS WOULD BE APPELLANT’S ARGUMENT THAT A CLAIMANT’S REPRESENTATIVE HAD NO RIGHT OF AUDIENCE

July 10, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Setting aside judgment

The Court considered a “Mazur” type argument in this application for permission to appeal. The appellant arguing that the claimant had never been lawfully represented at previous hearings. This argument did not get very far.  The judge indicated that, even…

THROWBACK FRIDAY: THE DEFENDANT IS NOT THE CLAIMANT'S KEEPER: ANOTHER CASE WHERE (MIS) SERVICE OF THE CLAIM FORM LED TO GRIEF

THROWBACK FRIDAY: THE DEFENDANT IS NOT THE CLAIMANT’S KEEPER: ANOTHER CASE WHERE (MIS) SERVICE OF THE CLAIM FORM LED TO GRIEF

July 10, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Service of the claim form, Serving documents

We are going back to July 2018 where the High Court overturned a first instance decision in favour of a claimant on a service of the claim form issue.  The judgment is particularly important because the first-instance judgment appeared to…

A JUDGE SHOULD NOT HAVE PREVENTED A DEFENDANT TENANT SPEAKING AT A POSSESSION HEARING JUST BECAUSE THEY HAD NOT FILED A DEFENCE: THE CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES HAVE PRIMACY OVER A PEREMPTORY ORDER

A JUDGE SHOULD NOT HAVE PREVENTED A DEFENDANT TENANT SPEAKING AT A POSSESSION HEARING JUST BECAUSE THEY HAD NOT FILED A DEFENCE: THE CIVIL PROCEDURE RULES HAVE PRIMACY OVER A PEREMPTORY ORDER

July 8, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Uncategorized

I am grateful to barrister James Stark for sending me a copy of this judgment which is important to all those involved in landlord and tenant litigation, but also raises interesting issues as to how far an order of the…

PERSONAL INJURY MATTERS 17 (1): LIABILITY CATCHUP (1):  PUB OPERATOR IS NOT VICARIOUSLY LIABLE FOR DOORMEN'S ACTS: A CONCLUSION REACHED "WITH REGRET"

PERSONAL INJURY MATTERS 17 (1): LIABILITY CATCHUP (1): PUB OPERATOR IS NOT VICARIOUSLY LIABLE FOR DOORMEN’S ACTS: A CONCLUSION REACHED “WITH REGRET”

July 7, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Members Content, Personal Injury

To ensure that those CLB readers who are personal injury litigators are not neglected there is a short series this work looking at recent decisions in relation to liability (a similar series on damages will feature in a few weeks…

COST BITES 411: HOW DOES A COURT DETERMINE THE AMOUNT OF AN INTERIM PAYMENT AS TO COSTS WHEN THE CASE HAS NOT BEEN BUDGETED? SHOULD A PAYMENT BE ORDERED AT ALL?

COST BITES 411: HOW DOES A COURT DETERMINE THE AMOUNT OF AN INTERIM PAYMENT AS TO COSTS WHEN THE CASE HAS NOT BEEN BUDGETED? SHOULD A PAYMENT BE ORDERED AT ALL?

July 7, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Costs, Interim Payments, Members Content

Knowledge of the principles dealing with payments on account is important for all litigators.  For successful parties it is a major aid in relation to cash flow. For the losing party a payment on account will reduce the interest payable. …

EXPERT WATCH 54 :  THE DEPUTY MASTER SHOULD NOT HAVE IGNORED THE EXPERT EVIDENCE BEFORE THE COURT:  IT WAS RELEVANT AND ADDRESSED THE CENTRAL ISSUE

EXPERT WATCH 54 : THE DEPUTY MASTER SHOULD NOT HAVE IGNORED THE EXPERT EVIDENCE BEFORE THE COURT: IT WAS RELEVANT AND ADDRESSED THE CENTRAL ISSUE

July 3, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Expert evidence, Experts, Members Content

We are looking at a case where, on appeal, the judge found that a Deputy Master fell into error by failing to take into account relevant expert evidence provided by a claimant.   The judge held that the Master had misunderstood…

A SOLICITOR SHOULD JUST NOT BE SAYING THIS IN A WITNESS STATEMENT: IT "STRAYED WELL BEYOND WHAT SHE COULD LEGALLY GIVE EVIDENCE ABOUT FROM HER OWN KNOWLEDGE INCLUDED HEARSAY FROM AN UNNAMED SOURCE AND INCLUDED STATEMENTS OF OPINION WHICH SHE DID NOT HAVE THE EXPERTISE TO GIVE..."

A SOLICITOR SHOULD JUST NOT BE SAYING THIS IN A WITNESS STATEMENT: IT “STRAYED WELL BEYOND WHAT SHE COULD LEGALLY GIVE EVIDENCE ABOUT FROM HER OWN KNOWLEDGE INCLUDED HEARSAY FROM AN UNNAMED SOURCE AND INCLUDED STATEMENTS OF OPINION WHICH SHE DID NOT HAVE THE EXPERTISE TO GIVE…”

July 3, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

There are numerous cases reported on this blog where judges have been critical of the “evidence” given by solicitors in witness statements.  In many cases, even on cursory examination, it transpires that the lawyer is not in a position to…

COST BITES 407: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS DECISION STRIKING OUT POINTS OF DISPUTE BECAUSE OF NON-AINSWORTH COMPLIANCE: JUDGMENT GIVEN TODAY

COST BITES 407: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS DECISION STRIKING OUT POINTS OF DISPUTE BECAUSE OF NON-AINSWORTH COMPLIANCE: JUDGMENT GIVEN TODAY

July 2, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Assessment of Costs, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content, Relief from sanctions

In this case the Court of Appeal overturned a decision, itself made on appeal, which had struck out a crucial paragraph of Points of Dispute to a bill of costs.  The crucial point here, however, is that this is not…

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 85: THERE IS NO "FREE PASS" WHEN AN ACTION IS BROUGHT ON BEHALF OF MULTIPLE CLAIMANTS: "THERE IS A DEFINITE SENSE OF THE CLAIMANTS THRASHING ABOUT, TRYING TO FIND ANY ISSUES WHICH COULD BE TRIED WHICH AVOIDED ANY INVESTIGATION OF ANY FACTS."

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 85: THERE IS NO “FREE PASS” WHEN AN ACTION IS BROUGHT ON BEHALF OF MULTIPLE CLAIMANTS: “THERE IS A DEFINITE SENSE OF THE CLAIMANTS THRASHING ABOUT, TRYING TO FIND ANY ISSUES WHICH COULD BE TRIED WHICH AVOIDED ANY INVESTIGATION OF ANY FACTS.”

July 2, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content, Statements of Case, Uncategorized

We are returning to this Court of Appeal decision for a second time.  Initially we looked at the judgment in relation to the outcome – that the claims could be brought together.  However there are important points made here in…

FIVE THOUSAND CLAIMANTS AND JUST EIGHT COURT FEES:  COURT OF APPEAL UPHOLDS DECISION ON CPR 7.3

FIVE THOUSAND CLAIMANTS AND JUST EIGHT COURT FEES: COURT OF APPEAL UPHOLDS DECISION ON CPR 7.3

July 2, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content

In this case the Court of Appeal upheld a decision that some 5,000 individual small value cases could proceed together as, essentially, one action.  The provisions of CPR 7.3 were considered and the Court held that the High Court Judge…

THE COURT WAS WRONG NOT TO STRIKE THE DEFENCE OUT: A FAILURE TO DISPUTE A POINT IN THE JERSEY COURTS MEANT IT WAS NOT OPEN TO A DEFENDANT TO ARGUE IT IN A SECOND ACTION

THE COURT WAS WRONG NOT TO STRIKE THE DEFENCE OUT: A FAILURE TO DISPUTE A POINT IN THE JERSEY COURTS MEANT IT WAS NOT OPEN TO A DEFENDANT TO ARGUE IT IN A SECOND ACTION

July 2, 2026 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Striking out, Summary assessment,

This is a case where, on appeal, it was held that it was not open to a defendant to bring an action because they had already had the ability to raise issues with a court in Jersey.  The judge held…

ASKING THE JUDGE QUESTIONS AFTER JUDGMENT IS DELIVERED: THEY HAVE TO BE NECESSARY TO ENABLE THE PARTIES TO UNDERSTAND THE REASONING OF THE DECISION (AND THESE GO TOO FAR...)

ASKING THE JUDGE QUESTIONS AFTER JUDGMENT IS DELIVERED: THEY HAVE TO BE NECESSARY TO ENABLE THE PARTIES TO UNDERSTAND THE REASONING OF THE DECISION (AND THESE GO TOO FAR…)

June 25, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Members Content

As you can see from the “Related Posts” section below this is not the first time we have considered the position where a losing litigant has written to the judge seeking “clarification” and where the judge has felt that this…

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 83: THE CASE OF THE SOLICITOR'S LIEN: THE JUDGE SHOULD NOT HAVE DECIDED AN APPLICATION TO STRIKE OUT ON THE BASIS OF AN UNPLEADED CASE

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 83: THE CASE OF THE SOLICITOR’S LIEN: THE JUDGE SHOULD NOT HAVE DECIDED AN APPLICATION TO STRIKE OUT ON THE BASIS OF AN UNPLEADED CASE

June 25, 2026 · by gexall · in Amendment, Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Statements of Case

We look at a case that relates to a solicitor’s lien and alleged breach of duty by those solicitors. It also deals with the basis upon which a judge should determine an application to strike out/summary judgment – making it…

THE COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS A JUDICIAL REVIEW DECISION IN FAVOUR OF A SOLICITOR: THE OMBUDSMAN GOT NOTHING WRONG (QUITE A LOT HERE ABOUT VULNERABLE CLIENTS AS WELL...)

THE COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS A JUDICIAL REVIEW DECISION IN FAVOUR OF A SOLICITOR: THE OMBUDSMAN GOT NOTHING WRONG (QUITE A LOT HERE ABOUT VULNERABLE CLIENTS AS WELL…)

June 23, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Costs, Members Content

In a judgment today the Court of Appeal have overturned a High Court decision that was (partially) in favour of a solicitor who had sought judicial review of a decision of the Legal Ombudsman.   The Court has restored the Ombudsman’s…

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 82: THERE MAY BE A POTENTIALLY VIABLE CLAIM HERE BUT YOU HAVEN'T PLEADED IT: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURN A DECISION TO GRANT PERMISSION TO AMEND COUNTERCLAIM

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 82: THERE MAY BE A POTENTIALLY VIABLE CLAIM HERE BUT YOU HAVEN’T PLEADED IT: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURN A DECISION TO GRANT PERMISSION TO AMEND COUNTERCLAIM

June 23, 2026 · by gexall · in Amendment, Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Statements of Case

Here we have an unusual example of the Court of Appeal overturning a decision granting permission to amend a statement of case (in this case a counterclaim).  The Court of Appeal held that the pleading did not give the information…

DESIGNATED CIVIL JUDGES SHOULD BE CAREFUL WHO IS GIVEN THE TASK OF TRYING COMPLEX TRIALS: COURT OF APPEAL MISSIVE TO DESIGNATED CIVIL JUDGES (& MANY OTHERS...)

DESIGNATED CIVIL JUDGES SHOULD BE CAREFUL WHO IS GIVEN THE TASK OF TRYING COMPLEX TRIALS: COURT OF APPEAL MISSIVE TO DESIGNATED CIVIL JUDGES (& MANY OTHERS…)

June 18, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Listing, Members Content, Personal Injury

Here we look at some comments made yesterday by the Court of Appeal.  The court allowed an appeal by a defendant in a personal injury case.  The case was heard by a Deputy District Judge.  The court was clear that…

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 81: IF YOU ARE RELYING ON A STATUTE THAT WASN'T ACTUALLY IN FORCE ON THE DATE IN QUESTION IT MAY HAVE BEEN BETTER FOR YOU TO HAVE PLEADED THIS...

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 81: IF YOU ARE RELYING ON A STATUTE THAT WASN’T ACTUALLY IN FORCE ON THE DATE IN QUESTION IT MAY HAVE BEEN BETTER FOR YOU TO HAVE PLEADED THIS…

June 17, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Statements of Case, Witness statements

Here we have an unusual case where the trial judge’s findings in favour of the defendant were overturned on appeal. One particular feature of this case is the fact that the claimant relied on a statute that was actually in…

COST BITES 402: DOES THE FACT THAT LEGAL FEES HAVE BEEN PAID BY RELATIVES MEAN THAT A RESPONDENT IS NOT LIABLE TO PAY COSTS? THE INDEMNITY PRINCIPLE CONSIDERED

COST BITES 402: DOES THE FACT THAT LEGAL FEES HAVE BEEN PAID BY RELATIVES MEAN THAT A RESPONDENT IS NOT LIABLE TO PAY COSTS? THE INDEMNITY PRINCIPLE CONSIDERED

June 16, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content

Here the court considered an argument that the indemnity principle meant that an unsuccessful respondent was not liable to pay the appellant’s costs.  It was clear that the fees in question had been paid by family members and not the…

ASSESSORS IN THE COURT OF APPEAL IN ADMIRALTY CASES: WHY WERE THEY NECESSARY? APPELLANTS MAY HAVE SUFFERED FROM THAT SINKING FEELING ...

ASSESSORS IN THE COURT OF APPEAL IN ADMIRALTY CASES: WHY WERE THEY NECESSARY? APPELLANTS MAY HAVE SUFFERED FROM THAT SINKING FEELING …

June 16, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content

I don’t know if there are many shipping lawyers who read this site. Here we have a very niche part of a judgment in relation to  Admiralty Court procedure.  The appeal was originally adjourned because there appeared to be a…

COST BITES 401: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS TRIAL JUDGE'S DECISION ON COSTS: THE COMPLICATIONS THAT OCCUR WHEN A COURT IS ASKED TO TAKE DISHONESTY INTO ACCOUNT WHEN MAKING AN AWARD OF COSTS...

COST BITES 401: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS TRIAL JUDGE’S DECISION ON COSTS: THE COMPLICATIONS THAT OCCUR WHEN A COURT IS ASKED TO TAKE DISHONESTY INTO ACCOUNT WHEN MAKING AN AWARD OF COSTS…

June 15, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Assessment of Costs, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Costs, Members Content, Uncategorized

Here the Court of Appeal grappled with some interesting issues when it overturned a trial judge’s decision to make no order for costs.   The Court of Appeal stated that although the judge had been critical of the conduct of the…

COST BITES 400: MASTERCARD FUNDER FAILS IN THE JUDICIAL REVIEW OF  ITS SHARE OF THE PROCEEDS : IT TURNS OUT THAT LITIGATION IS NOT PRICELESS

COST BITES 400: MASTERCARD FUNDER FAILS IN THE JUDICIAL REVIEW OF ITS SHARE OF THE PROCEEDS : IT TURNS OUT THAT LITIGATION IS NOT PRICELESS

June 10, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content

We have got to number 400 in this series. It is perhaps fitting we deal with (what may well be) the tail end of a mammoth case. Further it is a case where litigation funders felt that they had not…

THE JUDGE WAS ENTITLED TO BELIEVE THE CLAIMANT AND FIND THAT HE WAS NOT FUNDAMENTALLY DISHONEST: DEFENDANT'S APPEAL HITS A BARRIER

THE JUDGE WAS ENTITLED TO BELIEVE THE CLAIMANT AND FIND THAT HE WAS NOT FUNDAMENTALLY DISHONEST: DEFENDANT’S APPEAL HITS A BARRIER

June 8, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Fundamental Dishonesty, Members Content, Personal Injury

Here we look at what was, essentially, an attempt to appeal a trial judge’s findings of fact.  It did not fare well. The judge found that the trial judge was entitled to reach the conclusions he did. The absence of…

BACK TO BASICS MONDAY: THE DUTY TO SERVE A NOTICE OF APPEAL "AS SOON AS IS PRACTICABLE"

BACK TO BASICS MONDAY: THE DUTY TO SERVE A NOTICE OF APPEAL “AS SOON AS IS PRACTICABLE”

June 8, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions

This post arises from the observations of the judge in a case we looked at last week.  In essence it is not enough to simply issue a notice of appeal or an application notice.  The rules require that you serve…

AN OFFER TO SETTLE THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE PROVISION FOR COSTS MAY WELL BE INEFFECTIVE: IT CERTAINLY WILL NOT LEAD TO A PETITION BEING STRUCK OUT: COURT OF APPEAL DECISION TODAY

AN OFFER TO SETTLE THAT DOES NOT INCLUDE PROVISION FOR COSTS MAY WELL BE INEFFECTIVE: IT CERTAINLY WILL NOT LEAD TO A PETITION BEING STRUCK OUT: COURT OF APPEAL DECISION TODAY

June 5, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content

Here we look at an argument that a petition should be struck out because the respondents had made a reasonable offer to resolve the issues between the parties.  The Court of Appeal observed that the “reasonable offer” did not include…

COST BITES 395: A RETAINER WAS NOT A CONTENTIOUS BUSINESS AGREEMENT BECAUSE THE TERMS IN RELATION TO HOURLY RATES RENDERED IT TOO UNCERTAIN (COURT OF APPEAL DECISION YESTERDAY)

COST BITES 395: A RETAINER WAS NOT A CONTENTIOUS BUSINESS AGREEMENT BECAUSE THE TERMS IN RELATION TO HOURLY RATES RENDERED IT TOO UNCERTAIN (COURT OF APPEAL DECISION YESTERDAY)

June 4, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Assessment of Costs, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content

This appeal has been much discussed in the specialist press. A solicitor’s client argued that the terms of a retainer rendered in a Contentious Business Agreement. This would have given her greater scope to dispute the bills.  The Court of…

A CLAIMANT'S SUCCESSFUL APPEAL IN A HOUSING DISREPAIR CLAIM: THE DISTRICT JUDGE WAS WRONG TO ALLOCATE THE MATTER TO THE SMALL CLAIMS TRACK...

A CLAIMANT’S SUCCESSFUL APPEAL IN A HOUSING DISREPAIR CLAIM: THE DISTRICT JUDGE WAS WRONG TO ALLOCATE THE MATTER TO THE SMALL CLAIMS TRACK…

June 3, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Case Management, Civil Procedure, Members Content

I am grateful to Craig Leigh, for sending me a copy of this judgment in relation to an appeal about allocation in a housing disrepair case.   It deals with important principles relating to the allocation of housing disrepair cases. The…

COST BITES 394: COURT OVERTURNS DECISION THAT A CLAIMANT LANDLORD IS ENTITLED TO RECOVER THE COSTS: AWARD OF INTEREST ALSO OVERTURNED

COST BITES 394: COURT OVERTURNS DECISION THAT A CLAIMANT LANDLORD IS ENTITLED TO RECOVER THE COSTS: AWARD OF INTEREST ALSO OVERTURNED

June 3, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Costs, Interest, Members Content

This is a case where a decision as to costs and interests was overturned on appeal.  The Circuit Judge found that the claimant landlord had no entitlement to claim costs under the terms of the lease.  Further the claim for…

AN EASY MISTAKE TO MAKE: HOW A CRUCIAL TIME LIMIT FOR APPEALING WAS MISSED: MISLABELLING OF THE FILES: THIS WAS NOT A "MINOR ERROR..."

AN EASY MISTAKE TO MAKE: HOW A CRUCIAL TIME LIMIT FOR APPEALING WAS MISSED: MISLABELLING OF THE FILES: THIS WAS NOT A “MINOR ERROR…”

June 1, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content

Here we look at how a simple mistake in the naming of a file led to a potentially disastrous problem when it led to an appeal being out of time. The wrong documents were sent to the court when an…

AN APPEAL OVER A TIME ESTIMATE FOR TRIAL: THIS SHOULD NOT LAST 15 DAYS, NOR WILL IT BE DONE IN 5:  EIGHT DAYS REMAINS THE CORRECT CONCLUSION

AN APPEAL OVER A TIME ESTIMATE FOR TRIAL: THIS SHOULD NOT LAST 15 DAYS, NOR WILL IT BE DONE IN 5: EIGHT DAYS REMAINS THE CORRECT CONCLUSION

June 1, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content

This blog has covered issues relating to time estimates many times. I cannot recall, however, a case where there has been an appeal over a judicial determination of a time estimate for a trial. We have such a case here. …

BACK TO BASICS MONDAY: A LITIGANT CANNOT APPLY TO SET ASIDE A DECISION MADE WITHOUT A HEARING WHEN THEY SPECIFICALLY ASKED FOR THIS AND HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE SUBMISSIONS

BACK TO BASICS MONDAY: A LITIGANT CANNOT APPLY TO SET ASIDE A DECISION MADE WITHOUT A HEARING WHEN THEY SPECIFICALLY ASKED FOR THIS AND HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE SUBMISSIONS

June 1, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content

Here we look at a recent decision that has major practical implications for  anyone making an application, or anyone disgruntled with a court decision.  The applicant asked, specifically, for an application to be considered on paper.  The matter was considered…

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 79: COURT REJECTS CLAIMANT'S AMENDMENT APPLICATION BECAUSE THERE WERE "REASONABLY ARGUABLE" ISSUES IN RELATION TO LIMITATION

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 79: COURT REJECTS CLAIMANT’S AMENDMENT APPLICATION BECAUSE THERE WERE “REASONABLY ARGUABLE” ISSUES IN RELATION TO LIMITATION

May 29, 2026 · by gexall · in Amendment, Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Limitation, Members Content, Statements of Case

Here we continue the theme of today in looking at applications to amend.  In this case the application was unsuccessful because it sought to raise issues that may be subject to a limitation defence.  The judge rejected the argument that…

PERSONAL INJURY POINTS 15: THE STUDENTS LOAN COMPANY MAY BE AN "EMANATION OF THE STATE": SOME INTERESTING ISSUES HERE: THESE ARE ISSUES OF LAW - NOT ONE ON WHICH A WITNESS CAN EXPRESS AN OPINION OR VIEW...

PERSONAL INJURY POINTS 15: THE STUDENTS LOAN COMPANY MAY BE AN “EMANATION OF THE STATE”: SOME INTERESTING ISSUES HERE: THESE ARE ISSUES OF LAW – NOT ONE ON WHICH A WITNESS CAN EXPRESS AN OPINION OR VIEW…

May 28, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Personal Injury

The Court of Appeal considered some interesting issues in this case.  Firstly in relation to the direct applicability of EC directives; secondly in relation to whether a particular body was an emanation of the state.  It is not clear how…

SERVICE POINTS 44: LOCAL AUTHORITY FAILS TO SERVE PROPERLY ON INTERESTED PARTIES TO PROPOSED APPEAL: THE WHOLE APPEAL FAILS

SERVICE POINTS 44: LOCAL AUTHORITY FAILS TO SERVE PROPERLY ON INTERESTED PARTIES TO PROPOSED APPEAL: THE WHOLE APPEAL FAILS

May 27, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Service of the claim form, Serving documents

Here we have another case of a failure to serve a claim form properly.  This time a local authority failed to serve interested parties to an appeal because, rather than sending the claim forms to them personally, they were sent…

COST BITES 391: COURT OF APPEAL UPHOLDS DECISION THAT SOLICITOR'S BILL SHOULD BE ASSESSED AT "NIL":  THERE IS NO "RESTITUTIONARY" RIGHT TO DAMAGES WHERE THE CFA ITSELF MADE EXPRESS PROVISIONS FOR THESE CIRCUMSTANCES

COST BITES 391: COURT OF APPEAL UPHOLDS DECISION THAT SOLICITOR’S BILL SHOULD BE ASSESSED AT “NIL”: THERE IS NO “RESTITUTIONARY” RIGHT TO DAMAGES WHERE THE CFA ITSELF MADE EXPRESS PROVISIONS FOR THESE CIRCUMSTANCES

May 26, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Conditional Fee Agreements, Costs, Members Content

I wrote about this case in August 2025 “Here we have a case that could well bring tears to the eyes of any litigator who works on a conditional fee basis.  For the second time, on appeal, the claimant solicitor’s…

COST BITES 390: THE COURT OF APPEAL,  "LATE" WITNESS STATEMENTS, THE COPPERS AND THE COSTS

COST BITES 390: THE COURT OF APPEAL, “LATE” WITNESS STATEMENTS, THE COPPERS AND THE COSTS

May 22, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content, Relief from sanctions

We looked earlier at the Court of Appeal decision yesterday in relation to relief from sanctions.  Here we look at the judgment in relation to the costs of the hearing below and of the appeal itself.  As we shall see…

THE COURT OF APPEAL ALLOWED DEFENDANT TO RELY ON WITNESS STATEMENTS SERVED "LATE": THE CRUCIAL DISTINCTION BETWEEN "IN TIME" AND "OUT OF TIME" APPLICATIONS TO EXTEND TIME

THE COURT OF APPEAL ALLOWED DEFENDANT TO RELY ON WITNESS STATEMENTS SERVED “LATE”: THE CRUCIAL DISTINCTION BETWEEN “IN TIME” AND “OUT OF TIME” APPLICATIONS TO EXTEND TIME

May 22, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Witness statements

I am grateful to Barrister Simon Brindle for sending me a copy of the judgment of this Court of Appeal judgment given yesterday.  It relates primarily to the major distinction between an application made “ahead” of time and one made…

YOU CAN'T DELIBERATELY DECIDE TO IGNORE COURT (OR TRIBUNAL) DIRECTIONS: HMRC INVOLVED IN "CONTUMELIOUS" CONDUCT, ITS (LATE) APOLOGY GIVEN LITTLE WEIGHT

YOU CAN’T DELIBERATELY DECIDE TO IGNORE COURT (OR TRIBUNAL) DIRECTIONS: HMRC INVOLVED IN “CONTUMELIOUS” CONDUCT, ITS (LATE) APOLOGY GIVEN LITTLE WEIGHT

May 22, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Members Content, Relief from sanctions

Here we have a case of a litigant (the HMRC no less) making a deliberate decision to ignore Tribunal directions.  It then attempted to justify that decision by stating  “That was a deliberate and proportionate case management decision, taken in…

COST BITES 389: THE SRA IS LIABLE TO PAY THE COSTS OF AN APPEAL WHERE IT WAS THE ORIGINAL APPELLANT ITS POSITION IS "MORE AKIN TO THAT OF A NORMAL LITIGANT"

COST BITES 389: THE SRA IS LIABLE TO PAY THE COSTS OF AN APPEAL WHERE IT WAS THE ORIGINAL APPELLANT ITS POSITION IS “MORE AKIN TO THAT OF A NORMAL LITIGANT”

May 22, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil Procedure, Costs, Members Content

Here we consider an issue that has some relevance to the profession as a whole.  Should the SRA be liable to pay the costs of an appeal from the SDT?  In this case the SRA was the instigator of the…

WOULD BE APPELLANT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH SEVEN DAY DEADLINE: ARGUMENTS ABOUT "PUBLIC INTEREST" FAILS TO TAKE OFF: THE IMPORTANCE OF KNOWING TIME LIMITS...

WOULD BE APPELLANT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH SEVEN DAY DEADLINE: ARGUMENTS ABOUT “PUBLIC INTEREST” FAILS TO TAKE OFF: THE IMPORTANCE OF KNOWING TIME LIMITS…

May 21, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions

Here we have a case where the “would be” appellant failed to obtain permission to appeal out of time.  They failed to notice that the time limits for appealing this specific type of decision had been changed two months prior…

MAZUR MATTERS 62: THE REVISED COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENT: SOME SMALL BUT SIGNIFICANT REVISIONS

MAZUR MATTERS 62: THE REVISED COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENT: SOME SMALL BUT SIGNIFICANT REVISIONS

May 21, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content

There is a revised version of the Court of Appeal judgment in Mazur.  Some paragraphs were amended slightly (but significantly). These amendments do not appeal to have made their way to the version of the judgment that is publicly available….

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 76: APPLYING FOR PERMISSION TO AMEND THE DAY BEFORE THE COURT OF APPEAL HEARING, WITH NO NOTICE GIVEN: HAVE A GUESS HOW THIS WENT...

THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 76: APPLYING FOR PERMISSION TO AMEND THE DAY BEFORE THE COURT OF APPEAL HEARING, WITH NO NOTICE GIVEN: HAVE A GUESS HOW THIS WENT…

May 21, 2026 · by gexall · in Amendment, Appeals, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Default judgment,, Members Content, Statements of Case

There have been quite a few cases about pleading recently.  This case is interesting because it makes the point that after  a default judgment is entered a claimant is only entitled to have damages assessed on the basis of their…

THE POSITION FOLLOWING DEATH OF A PARTY: THE FAMILY PROCEDURE RULES CANNOT "BORROW" PROVISIONS FROM THE CPR: APPEAL STRUCK OUT

THE POSITION FOLLOWING DEATH OF A PARTY: THE FAMILY PROCEDURE RULES CANNOT “BORROW” PROVISIONS FROM THE CPR: APPEAL STRUCK OUT

May 19, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content

This blog has looked, many times, at the problems caused by the death of a party during the course of litigation.  Here we look at a problem that occurred in the Family Court.  The fundamental point here is that the …

COST BITES 388: A COMPANY CANNOT CLAIM ITS OWN EMPLOYEE'S TIME AS LEGAL COSTS WHEN IT WAS REPRESENTED ON AN APPEAL

COST BITES 388: A COMPANY CANNOT CLAIM ITS OWN EMPLOYEE’S TIME AS LEGAL COSTS WHEN IT WAS REPRESENTED ON AN APPEAL

May 19, 2026 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Assessment of Costs, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content

Here we have a reiteration of a long established principle as to costs. A company can only recover legal costs on an assessment, not the costs of being a litigant.  Here the appellant sought to recover both.  The Costs Judge…

← Previous 1 2 3 … 31 Next →

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Subscription notifies you of a new post, it does not give you access to members' content.

Join 12.4K other subscribers

Recent Posts

  • COST BITES 461: JUDGE ALLOWS LITIGANTS IN PERSON TO RECOVER THE COSTS OF AN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE SUBSCRIPTION: “THE SUM CLAIMED WAS REASONABLY INCURRED AND PROPORTIONATE”
  • THE COURT REFUSED AN ADJOURNMENT OF SEVEN-DAY TRIAL FOR A £300,000 CLAIM: THE IMPORTANCE OF EVIDENCE: “THE BALANCE IN THIS CASE LIES FIRMLY IN FAVOUR OF REFUSING THE APPLICATION TO ADJOURN THE TRIAL”
  • MORE ISSUES FOLLOWING A DRAFT JUDGMENT BEING CIRCULATED: NEW EVIDENCE, REPORTING RESTRICTIONS AND THE COSTS CONSEQUENCES OF UNSUCCESSFUL APPLICATIONS
  • ASKING A JUDGE FOR FURTHER REASONS AFTER A DRAFT JUDGMENT HAS CIRCULATED: THE GUIDANCE THE COURT OF APPEAL GAVE IN A & l
  • TRYING TO REOPEN FINDINGS AFTER RECEIVING A DRAFT JUDGMENT: THE COURT IS NOT OBLIGED TO DEAL WITH EVERY ARGUMENT AND A REQUEST FOR FURTHER FINDINGS IS NOT AN OPPORTUNITY TO REARGUE THE CASE

Top Posts

A PRACTICAL AI PRIMER FOR LAWYERS: THE SECOND EDITION OF "ANDREW AND THE MARVELLOUS ANALYTICAL ENGINE": MAJOR ADDITIONS TO A FAST MOVING AND IMPORTANT AREA
COSTS BITES 459: A SUCCESSFUL CLAIMANT SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DEPRIVED OF THEIR COSTS BECAUSE PRECEDENT U WAS SERVED FIVE HOURS LATE
THE COURT REFUSED AN ADJOURNMENT OF SEVEN-DAY TRIAL FOR A £300,000 CLAIM: THE IMPORTANCE OF EVIDENCE: "THE BALANCE IN THIS CASE LIES FIRMLY IN FAVOUR OF REFUSING THE APPLICATION TO ADJOURN THE TRIAL"
COST BITES 459: YOU CAN SPEND £1 MILLION ON COSTS, ESSENTIALLY "WIN" THE CASE BUT STILL NOT RECOVER THE COSTS: HIGH COURT CONSIDERS APPEAL IN A VERY EXPENSIVE BOUNDARY DISPUTE
COSTS BITES 461: THE £14,113 BILL THAT BECAME A £58,543 DEBT (PLUS INTEREST...): COSTS WERE HIGH "IN LARGE PART, THAT APPEARS TO BE AS A RESULT OF THE EXTRA WORK REQUIRED TO ADDRESS THE DEFENDANT'S UNMERITORIOUS AND WIDE-RANGING SUBMISSIONS"

Archives

Blogroll

  • Fatal Accident Law
  • Legal Futures
  • Personal injury: Liability and Damages

Books

  • Munkman & Exall on Damages for Personal Injuries and Death 15th ed
  • The APIL Guide to Fatal Accidents 4th edition

Useful Links

  • Buntools (for preparing PDF Bundles)
  • Kings Chambers
  • Kings Chambers Costs & Litigation Funding
  • Kings Chambers Serious Injury
  • The Civil Procedure Rules
  • The Law Society Gazette
  • The National Archives Recently Published Judgments
  • The Senior Court Costs Office Guide 2025
  • www.Bailii.org

Copyright

© Gordon Exall, Exall Legal Training, Civil Litigation Brief, 2013-2026. Unauthorised use and or duplication of the material contained on this blog without permission is strictly prohibited.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.

To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Membership Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertising Policy
  • Copyright
  • Legal Disclaimer

Copyright © 2026 Civil Litigation Brief ®

Powered by Big Yellow Workshop

Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.