WITNESS CREDIBILITY; DOCUMENTS; RECOLLECTION AND PLAYING AWAY FROM HOME WHEN THERE ARE MILLIONS AT STAKE
Earlier posts have looked at the issue of witness credibility in the context of civil trials. Here we look at the issue of witness evidence in the context of a multi million pound dispute between corporations. The judgment, given earlier…
MORE ON EXPERTS: NON-COMPLIANCE WITH THE RULES TAINTS THE EVIDENCE BADLY
We have already looked at one of the observations on experts by HH Simon Barker QC in Bacciotinni & Cook -v- Gotelle & Goldsmith [2014] EWHC 3257 Ch. There we looked at “over eager” experts. The judge also had something to…
WHICH WITNESS IS GOING TO BE BELIEVED? A HIGH COURT DECISION ASSESSING THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES
It is essential that litigators have a keen understanding of how witness evidence is likely to be assessed at trial. Many trials take place precisely because there is a conflict of evidence between the witnesses. An example of a close…
OVER EAGER EXPERTS JUST DO NOT HELP: THEY HINDER AND HARM THE CASES OF THOSE WHO CALL THEM
Several preliminary remarks of HH Simon Barker QC in Bacciotinni & Cook -v- Gotelle & Goldsmith [2014] EWHC 3257 Ch underline the dangers of an “over eager” expert witness making comments which undermine their own evidence and taint the case…