COST BITES 461: JUDGE ALLOWS LITIGANTS IN PERSON TO RECOVER THE COSTS OF AN ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE SUBSCRIPTION: “THE SUM CLAIMED WAS REASONABLY INCURRED AND PROPORTIONATE”
In this case the judge allowed successful litigants in person to recover the costs of an artificial intelligence subscription. He rejected the argument that, in this case, that was an overhead. Rather it was something that had been purchased specifically…
THE COURT REFUSED AN ADJOURNMENT OF SEVEN-DAY TRIAL FOR A £300,000 CLAIM: THE IMPORTANCE OF EVIDENCE: “THE BALANCE IN THIS CASE LIES FIRMLY IN FAVOUR OF REFUSING THE APPLICATION TO ADJOURN THE TRIAL”
In this case the claimant sought an adjournment of a a seven-day on the morning of that trial. The judge considered the reasons and arguments put forward and did not accept they warranted an adjournment. Consequently the claimant left the…
MORE ISSUES FOLLOWING A DRAFT JUDGMENT BEING CIRCULATED: NEW EVIDENCE, REPORTING RESTRICTIONS AND THE COSTS CONSEQUENCES OF UNSUCCESSFUL APPLICATIONS
We are looking at another cases the considers the steps the court should take following the circulation of a draft judgment. The first issue relates to an attempt to reopen the judgment due to “new evidence” (in circumstances where the…
ASKING A JUDGE FOR FURTHER REASONS AFTER A DRAFT JUDGMENT HAS CIRCULATED: THE GUIDANCE THE COURT OF APPEAL GAVE IN A & l
In the judgment we looked at earlier today the judge commented that the correspondence in relation to the draft judgment did not follow the guidance in A and L (Children), Re [2011] EWCA Civ 1205. It is sensible to review…
TRYING TO REOPEN FINDINGS AFTER RECEIVING A DRAFT JUDGMENT: THE COURT IS NOT OBLIGED TO DEAL WITH EVERY ARGUMENT AND A REQUEST FOR FURTHER FINDINGS IS NOT AN OPPORTUNITY TO REARGUE THE CASE
There have been a number of recent cases where parties have sought to use a draft judgment as an attempt to re-open the case. This is the third post on this issue this month (and it won’t be the last…)…
LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 5: DEFENDING A CLAIM BASED ON A COUNTERFACTUAL — 10 KEY POINTS FOR DEFENDANTS
A post earlier today dealt with the matters that a claimant must plead and establish if they are claiming damages based on a “counterfactual”. This blog must, of course, be balanced and now we look at these issues from the…
LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 4 : PLEADING AND PROVING THE COUNTERFACTUAL: 10 KEY POINTS FOR CLAIMANTS
The case we looked at yesterday showed, starkly, the difficulties a claimant can have in proving a “counterfactual”. That is proving that the claimant, or possibly, others would have acted differently if the defendant had not breached their duty. In…
WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: RECOLLECTION OF MEETINGS TWO YEARS EARLIER IS LIKELY TO BE IMPERFECT: THE FACT THAT THE CLAIMANT’S WITNESSES “SETTLED ON A CONCLUSION THAT EXACTLY ACCORDS WITH THE CLAIMANT’S COMMERCIAL INTERESTS IS UNSURPRISING” BUT NEEDS TO BE “TREATED WITH CAUTION”
Here we have another case where a party’s case rested largely on witness recollection. The judge found that the witnesses were giving an account they now believed to be true, however ” their evidence is unlikely to be reliable on…
PROVING THINGS 307: FAILING TO PROVE THE COUNTERFACTUAL: THE CLAIMANTS ESTABLISHED NEGLIGENCE BUT FAILED TO PROVE WHAT THEY WOULD HAVE DONE IF GIVEN THE CORRECT ADVICE
Many of the cases in this series are, in reality, about not proving things. Here we are back to traditional territory – a failure to prove damages. Proving a “counterfactual” is perhaps one of the most challenging aspects of civil…
ENFORCEMENT BULLETIN No. 8: THE BANK GETS ITS CARS BACK: SUMMARY JUDGMENT, UNDISCLOSED COMMISSIONS AND THE IMPORTANCE OF PLEADING A DEFENCE THAT CAN ACTUALLY DEFEAT THE CLAIM
Here we have a case where the judge at first instance declined to order the return of vehicles which were owned by the claimant under the terms of a hire purchase agreement. The case gave rise to some procedural issues….
PROVING THINGS 306: PROVING LOSS OF PROFITS AND OF CAPITAL VALUE WHEN SCHOOL PUPIL NUMBERS DECLINE: THE “REFLECTIVE LOSS” PRINCIPLE ALSO CONSIDERED
This blog has always paid close attention to claims for loss of income and loss of profits. We have seen plenty of examples where claimants have failed to prove causation or been unable to quantify the losses alleged. This case…
COSTS BITES 461: THE £14,113 BILL THAT BECAME A £58,543 DEBT (PLUS INTEREST…): COSTS WERE HIGH “IN LARGE PART, THAT APPEARS TO BE AS A RESULT OF THE EXTRA WORK REQUIRED TO ADDRESS THE DEFENDANT’S UNMERITORIOUS AND WIDE-RANGING SUBMISSIONS”
There are some defences that are ill advised. Here we look at a case where an original £14,133 (with an offer of a discount of a third) was not paid and the action defended. This led to a judgment for…
COST BITES 460: CONDUCT AND COSTS: HOW FAR SHOULD A PARTY’S CONDUCT EFFECT THE ORDER FOR COSTS? DOES THERE HAVE TO BE A CAUSAL LINK BETWEEN THE CONDUCT AND THE INCREASE IN COSTS?
In the previous post we looked at case where the trial judge had concluded that a boundary dispute ended in a “score-draw” for costs purposes. There was a second element to the appeal, the judge considered the issue of conduct….
COST BITES 459: YOU CAN SPEND £1 MILLION ON COSTS, ESSENTIALLY “WIN” THE CASE BUT STILL NOT RECOVER THE COSTS: HIGH COURT CONSIDERS APPEAL IN A VERY EXPENSIVE BOUNDARY DISPUTE
This judgment today carries a clear warning to all litigants (and litigators) about costs, in particular as to whether they will be recoverable. It is a case where the appellant spent over £1 million in costs defending and counterclaiming in…
THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 104: YOU CANNOT RESCUE A DEFECTIVE COUNTERCLAIM BY PUTTING THE MISSING PARTICULARS IN A WITNESS STATEMENT
In this case the judge struck out part of the counterclaim. The counterclaiming defendant was given an opportunity to amend. However the judge makes the basic point that the issues they raised should have been fully and properly particularised in…
BACK TO BASICS MONDAY: FILING COSTS SCHEDULES AND COST BUDGETS ON TIME: THE RULES AND USEFUL LINKS: TEN KEY POINTS
Last week we had a detailed look at the problems that can occur when a costs schedule is served late. We have also looked many times at problems relating to the late service of costs budget. Our main aim, of…
A PRACTICAL AI PRIMER FOR LAWYERS: THE SECOND EDITION OF “ANDREW AND THE MARVELLOUS ANALYTICAL ENGINE”: MAJOR ADDITIONS TO A FAST MOVING AND IMPORTANT AREA
The use (and often misuse) of artificial intelligence has featured regularly in this blog over the past three years. Initially it was a litigant in person, however a large number of practising lawyers have fallen foul of hallucinations. Further it…
ENFORCEMENT BULLETIN 7: SECOND ATTEMPT TO ENFORCE A FOREIGN JUDGMENT WAS (AMONG OTHER THINGS) AN ABUSE OF PROCESS
Here we are looking at an unusual situation in which a claimant sought to enforce the same judgment in two different ways. The first application to register a Spanish judgment was dismissed because it was no longer enforceable in Spain. …
LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 3: WHAT IF YOU HAVE SERVED A SCHEDULE OF COSTS LATE?
A post earlier this morning dealt with a successful appeal where a claimant had originally not been awarded any costs because the schedule of costs for the trial had been served five hours late. “… the failure may at one…
THROWBACK FRIDAY: “SKELETON ARGUMENTS – DO THEM PROPERLY OR YOU WON’T GET PAID” (NOVEMBER 2014)
The issue of compliant skeleton arguments has been featured on this blog for more than a decade. Here we look back to November 2014 and some pertinent observations from Jackson L.J. “The appellant’s skeleton argument in this case does not…
COSTS BITES 459: A SUCCESSFUL CLAIMANT SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DEPRIVED OF THEIR COSTS BECAUSE PRECEDENT U WAS SERVED FIVE HOURS LATE
What should the court’s response be if a Schedule of Costs is served late? Here the Precedent U was served 5 hours and, after the claimant was successful at trial (and beat its own Part 36 offer) it was deprived…
YOU CAN’T SIMPLY WITHDRAW AN APPEAL WITHOUT PERMISSION: APPELLANT SEEKS TO WITHDRAW APPEAL & DOESN’T ATTEND – BUT THE APPEAL GOES AHEAD AND THE APPELLANT WINS …
There can be few cases where an appellant has sought to withdraw an appeal and that application has been refused. There may be fewer still where, after refusing, and with the appellant absent a court has gone ahead and considered…
PROVING THINGS 305 : DEFENDANT FAILS TO ESTABLISH ANY BREACHES AND (IN ANY EVENT) HAD MADE A PROFIT HERE NOT A LOSS: IF YOU PLEAD DAMAGES YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO PROVE THEM
This is far from the first case where a litigant has taken a claim for damages to trial and failed, demonstrably, to show that it has suffered any loss. The principles in relation to proving damages on a counterclaim are…
SERVICE POINTS 59: AN APPLICATION TO EXTEND TIME TO SERVE THE PARTICULARS OF CLAIM DID NOT EXTEND TIME FOR THE CLAIM FORM: NEITHER DID THE ACTUAL STRIKING OUT OF THE ACTION…
Here we have an appeal which several procedural issues. Firstly the claimant could not really justify seeking an extension of time of 18 months for service of the Particulars of Claim. Secondly (and significantly) despite taking several procedural steps the…
THERE HAS NOT BEEN FULL AND FRANK DISCLOSURE: THE DIFFICULTIES WHEN LITIGATION SPANS SEVERAL JURISDICTIONS: “THE SUPPOSED EXPLANATIONS BELATEDLY OFFERED … AMOUNT TO LITTLE MORE THAN AN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF THE FAILING WITH A RATHER LAME CONFESSION OF INABILITY TO EXPLAIN HOW OR WHY IT OCCURRED”
We have seen many examples of litigants coming to grief because of a failure to comply with the duty of full and frank disclosure, particularly when making an application for an injunction. The judge in this case was clear that…
COST BITES 458: “PLEASE JUDGE WE’D LIKE MORE TIME TO PAY THE COSTS”: THE RULES AND CASES CONSIDERED
Earlier today we looked at two cases about the award of costs after judgment. In both cases the paying party sought additional time to pay. Asking for extra time is sometimes an inevitable request by paying parties. “if a party…
COST BITES 456: THE CLAIMANT HAD SUCCEEDED ON ALL FOUGHT POINTS: THERE WOULD BE NO REDUCTION OF ITS COSTS: INDEMNITY COSTS IN A LANDLORD AND TENANT DISPUTE
It is now relatively common for a losing (and paying) party to seek a deduction from the successful side’s costs. Here we look at a case where such an argument was rejected. The case also serves as a reminder that…
WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: WHY A SOLICITOR NEEDS TAKES TO TAKE GREAT WHEN MAKING STATEMENTS: “AN UNIMPRESSIVE WITNESS ON WHOSE EVIDENCE I CAN PLACE LITTLE RELIANCE” (IS WHAT WE DON’T WANT TO SEE…)
We have looked at many cases where lawyers have made witness statements which have led to difficulties. We have an example here in a professional negligence action against a firm of solicitors where the judge found that he could “place…
THE CURRENT IMPORTANCE OF PLEADINGS 103: “THE RESPONSIBILITY OF PLEADING THE CLAIM RESTS ON THE CLAIMANT” (OH, AND MATTERS CANNOT BE ADDED IN A SKELETON ARGUMENT SERVED THE DAY BEFORE TRIAL…)
Here we have a case where the claimant complained about the judge finding for the defendant on unpleaded matters. It was held on appeal that the claimant had not particularised the case fully and properly. The difficulty was added to…
THE POWER TO GRANT AN INJUNCTION NORMALLY REQUIRES A CAUSE OF ACTION: (ONE OF) THE DIFFICULTIES OF AN ANONYMOUS LITIGANT
There has been much press coverage, and much speculation, about the recent application to prevent publication of information by an anonymous celebrity. As litigators we are, of course, not interested in this. Of much more interest (to us) are the…
THE CRITICAL IMPORTANCE OF COMPLYING WITH TIME LIMITS: “THERE WAS A WHOLESALE FAILURE TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE DEFAULTS”; “IT WAS ALL AS IF COMPLIANCE WERE OPTIONAL”
Over the years we have seen some strongly worded judgments on failure to comply with the rules. Few are as strongly worded as this. The judge felt that the defendant felt it was entitled to provide documents late; there was…
BACK TO BASICS MONDAY: THE PROBLEMS THAT CAN OCCUR WITH THE CONTENTS OF THE CLAIM FORM: TEN KEY POINTS
Earlier this morning we looked at the revised form N1 and the problems that could be caused now there is an option to put the defendant’s email address on the form. This gives rise to an opportunity to look at…
PROVING THINGS 304 : FUNDAMENTAL DISHONESTY ESTABLISHED IN A £7 MILLION CLAIM: “THE WASTE OF PUBLIC RESOURCES CAUSED BY THE CLAIMANT’S DISHONESTY IS SCANDALOUS”
There are some cases that are on the “extreme” end of fundamental dishonesty litigation. This may well be one of them. The claimant brought a claim for £7 million in damages. However there was evidence that he had largely recovered…
TRYING TO RE-OPEN THE CASE AFTER BEING SENT A DRAFT JUDGMENT: “IT IS NOT INTENDED TO PROVIDE AN OPPORTUNITY TO ANY PARTY … TO REOPEN OR REARGUE THE CASE”
For the second time in a fortnight we are looking at an attempt to persuade a judge to re-open their decision after a draft judgment has been sent out. This approach had the same result as the previous case. “This…
FORM N1 HAS BEEN SLIGHTLY AMENDED: THIS COULD BE A TRAP FOR THE UNWARY: PUTTING THE DEFENDANT’S EMAIL ADDRESS ON THE CLAIM FORM DOES NOT CHANGE THE RULES FOR SERVICE…
Form N1 had a slight amendment made on the 23rd October. It is a very minor amendment, but one that practitioners need to be aware of. The one major problem that it could give rise to is if practitioners (or…
COST BITES 454: PERSISTENT DISHONESTY LEADS TO INDEMNITY COSTS AGAINST ALL THE DEFENDANTS : “THEY WERE ALL IN IT TOGETHER”: LIMITED MEANS DID NOT JUSTIFY REFUSING AN ORDER FOR AN INTERIM PAYMENT OF COSTS
There are a number of costs issues considered in this judgment. Should indemnity costs be awarded? Should each defendant be liable to the same extent? Should the defendants’ financial position play a part in the decision on costs? Should there…
THROWBACK FRIDAY “AN OBJECT LESSON IN HOW MODERN LITIGATION SHOULD NOT BE CONDUCTED” (WITH THE ADDED BONUS OF AN OBJECT LESSON IN HOW NOT TO DRAW UP A COURT ORDER): NOVEMBER 2013
This case provides two object lessons. Firstly in how not to conduct litigation; secondly in how not to draw up a court order. Both points are important. The second issue is a remarkable attempt by a part to “re-write” a…
LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 2: WHEN A SOLICITOR MOVES FIRMS: TEN POINTS ON FORMER CLIENTS, CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION AND INFORMATION BARRIERS
Earlier this week we looked at a case where a defendant made an application to prevent the claimant’s solicitors continue acting. This was on the basis that a solicitor who he had dealings with at a previous firm had now…
WRITING LETTERS TO THE JUDGE AFTER A DRAFT JUDGMENT IS CIRCULATED: “THIS IS ABOUT AS FAR AWAY FROM THE CONDUCT OF SOLICITORS CONDUCTING LITIGATION AS IT IS POSSIBLE TO GET”
We have had many examples of parties writing to the court after receiving a draft judgment. On occasions such correspondence has been ill-advised. However I cannot recall any case where the letter from a losing party’s solicitor was as vitriolic…
COST BITES 453: COSTS AWARD TO A LITIGANT IN PERSON: “… THESE ASSESSMENTS ARE MADE WITH A FAIRLY BROAD BRUSH”: THESE ARE NOT NOMINAL AMOUNTS
There are relatively few cases where the court assesses the costs of litigant in person. We have an example here. It is a useful reminder of the “upper limit” the rules apply to costs claimed and the factors the courts…
REMEMBER THAT GIVING AN UNDERTAKING AS TO DAMAGES WHEN OBTAINING AN INJUNCTION CAN BE EXPENSIVE (VERY EXPENSIVE) IN THIS CASE IT MAY RUN INTO TENS OF MILIONS (OF DOLLARS…)
An applicant for an injunction normally has to give an undertaking as to damages. We have seen several cases where the applicant has had to pay damages and where this has been an expensive process. We have another example here. …
THE COURT REFUSES DEFENDANT’S APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER THAT THE CLAIMANT’S SOLICITORS CEASE TO ACT FOR HER: THERE IS NO AUTOMATIC CONFLICT AND EVIDENCE IS REQUIRED
It is not at all unusual for solicitors to move firms. It is often the case that the new firm will be engaged in cases which involve the solicitor’s previous firm. Is the “new” firm conflicted thereafter and must it…
WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: DOUBLE HEARSAY IS STILL EVIDENCE: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS BANKRUPTCY ORDER AFTER WITNESS EVIDENCE WAS WRONGLY DISCOUNTED
For many litigators the way in which the courts approach written evidence is just as (arguably more) important than the way witness evidence is considered at trial. A working knowledge of the way in which the court treats evidence in…
ANOTHER CASE ABOUT SETTLEMENT: “FULL AND FINAL SETTLEMENT” OF WHAT? THE IMPORTANCE OF KNOWING PRECISELY WHAT HAS BEEN SETTLED
Issues relating to the settlement of cases have been a theme this week. Here we look at a case where the defendant argued that the action against it should be struck out because it had been resolved in an earlier…
HERE WE HAVE A CLAIMANT TAKING A LOT OF CHANCES IN RELATION TO COMPLIANCE AND PROCEDURE: BUT THEY LIVE TO FIGHT ANOTHER DAY
This case is an example of a claimant taking a number of chances in relation to procedure. Firstly in not complying with the pre-action protocol; secondly in not serving the particulars of claim timeously; then applying for a stay after…
MORE HALLUCINATION POINTS TO WATCH: AI CAN SIMPLY MAKE THINGS UP (ANOTHER WARNING FROM THE COURTS): THE MATERIAL PRODUCED CAN BE “PLAUSIBLE BUT INACCURATE”
We are looking at another case where the use of Artificial Intelligence has led to a litigant having problems. We have many examples of AI hallucinating cases. Here AI simply added words to legislation. Those words did not exist… …
WHICH CITY IS BEST FOR THE TRIAL? A JUDGMENT FROM THE USA AND ITS (IMAGINED) ENGLISH EQUIVALENT: “THE COURT CAN FURTHER REASSURE VISITING PRACTITIONERS THAT THE COURTHOUSE HAS ELECTRIC LIGHTING, INDOOR PLUMBING AND DOORS WHICH OPEN WITHOUT THE ASSISTANCE OF A WHIPPET.”
We have looked many times at decisions as to which particular city is most appropriate for a case to be heard. Someone recently brought my attention to the judgment of District Judge Kent set out below. This is a judgment…
COST BITES 451: THE IMPACT OF A STATUTORY REQUIREMENT ON A COSTS BUDGET: THE STATUTE TAKES PRECEDENCE OVER THE CPR: THE DIFFERENCE TO A BUDGET WHEN THE COURT IS COMPELLED TO TAKE THE FINANCIAL POSITION OF THE PARTIES INTO ACCOUNT
The Court of Appeal considered an unusual aspect of costs budgeting. Does a statutory requirement that the courts take into account the financial position of the parties when considering costs have any impact on the budgeting process? If it does…
WHAT YOU SAY (OR DON’T SAY) IN A MEDIATION, AND AFTERWARDS, CAN BE OF CRITICAL IMPORTANCE: COURT SETS ASIDE A SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND ORDERS REPAYMENT
This is an unusual case in which the claimant successfully set aside an agreed settlement. It argued that there had been fraudulent misrepresentation. Even more unusually it obtained an order for repayment and recission on a summary judgment application. “In…
PROFESSIONAL NEGLIGENCE NEWS 6 : CLAIMANT FAILS TO PROVE SOLICITORS WERE NEGLIGENT IN ADVISING UPON SETTLEMENT (IN FACT IT FAILS TO PROVE A LOT OF OTHER MATTERS AS WELL…)
Most disputed claims eventually settle. Some clients may be dissatisfied with the terms of settlement. Here we look at a case where the claimants allege that their former solicitors had been negligent in settling two sets of proceedings. The case…

You must be logged in to post a comment.