Civil Litigation Brief ®
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Membership Plans
  • Webinars
  • Login
Updates and Commentary on Civil Procedure, by Gordon Exall, Barrister, Kings Chambers
Browse: Home » Witness statements » Page 17
PROVING THINGS 83: WHEN A DEFENDANT DOES NOT GIVE EVIDENCE, ADVERSE INFERENCES CAN BE DRAWN: STAGED CRASH ESTABLISHED

PROVING THINGS 83: WHEN A DEFENDANT DOES NOT GIVE EVIDENCE, ADVERSE INFERENCES CAN BE DRAWN: STAGED CRASH ESTABLISHED

January 18, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In UK Insurance Ltd v Gentry [2018] EWHC 37 (QB) Mr Justice Teare considered what inferences can properly be drawn when a defendant, accused of dishonesty, does not give evidence. KEY POINTS The claimant brought a case in deceit – alleging…

SEEKING AN EXTENSION OF TIME - WHEN YOU ARE 9 1/2 YEARS LATE: THE IMPORTANCE OF A SOLICITOR KEEPING A RECORD

SEEKING AN EXTENSION OF TIME – WHEN YOU ARE 9 1/2 YEARS LATE: THE IMPORTANCE OF A SOLICITOR KEEPING A RECORD

January 9, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Limitation, Members Content, Uncategorized, Witness statements

Section 4 of the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 provides that a claim under the Act should normally be brought within six months of the date on which representation is taken out.  An action brought at a…

HAS THE WITNESS FOR THE OTHER SIDE WRITTEN A BOOK? THAT IS AN INTERESTING QUESTION: RESEARCHING AN EXPERT BEFORE THEY GIVE EVIDENCE

HAS THE WITNESS FOR THE OTHER SIDE WRITTEN A BOOK? THAT IS AN INTERESTING QUESTION: RESEARCHING AN EXPERT BEFORE THEY GIVE EVIDENCE

January 8, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Credibility of experts, Experts, Members Content, Witness statements

I have lost track of the number of interlocutory judgments there have been in the case of  Kimathi & Ors v Foreign and Commonwealth Office. The latest judgment being at [2017] EWHC 3054 (QB). This  judgment deals with the issue…

THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: WHEN THE DEFENDANT'S OWN EVIDENCE AMOUNTS TO A HOME GOAL

THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: WHEN THE DEFENDANT’S OWN EVIDENCE AMOUNTS TO A HOME GOAL

January 7, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

This blog has looked many times at the issue of witness credibility and why the judge prefers the evidence of one witness over another . This was an issue to the fore in the judgment of Mr Justice Green in  Khakshouri…

"SOMETIMES AN UNIMPRESSIVE WITNESS SPEAKS THE TRUTH": FACT FINDING AND THE CIVIL COURTS: PRIVY COUNCIL OVERTURN FINDINGS OF FACT

“SOMETIMES AN UNIMPRESSIVE WITNESS SPEAKS THE TRUTH”: FACT FINDING AND THE CIVIL COURTS: PRIVY COUNCIL OVERTURN FINDINGS OF FACT

January 5, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Expert evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

In Cleare v The Attorney General & Ors (Bahamas) [2017] UKPC 38 the Privy Council was scathing of the method of fact finding of the trial judge. The judge erred in failing to consider the significance of medical evidence. ” It…

2018: A NEW YEAR RESOLUTION FOR LITIGATORS: DON'T LEAVE MATTERS TO CHANCE - LEARN TO PROVE DAMAGES

2018: A NEW YEAR RESOLUTION FOR LITIGATORS: DON’T LEAVE MATTERS TO CHANCE – LEARN TO PROVE DAMAGES

January 2, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Damages, Members Content, Witness statements

For nearly two years this blog has documented issues (and often failures) when parties fail to prove things.  In a surprising number of cases the failures are very basic. Proving things is the basic job of the litigator. However we…

CIVIL LITIGATION AND THE MARTIAL ARTS: MCGANN -V- BISPING: ROUND 3: LATE WITNESS STATEMENTS AND "IMPLICIT" ORDERS FOR RELIEF FROM SANCTIONS

CIVIL LITIGATION AND THE MARTIAL ARTS: MCGANN -V- BISPING: ROUND 3: LATE WITNESS STATEMENTS AND “IMPLICIT” ORDERS FOR RELIEF FROM SANCTIONS

December 27, 2017 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Witness statements

We have already looked twice at the “sparring” arguments in relation to procedure in the case of  McGann v Bisping [2017] EWHC 2951 (Comm). A further procedural issue arose as to whether a party was debarred from calling evidence at all. The…

CIVIL LITIGATION AND THE MARTIAL ARTS: MCGANN -V- BISPING: ROUND 2: WHEN A WITNESS DISCUSSES THEIR EVIDENCE

December 20, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Conduct, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment in McGann v Bisping [2017] EWHC 2951 (Comm) deals with numerous procedural issues, many of which arose in the course of the trial. We have looked at one of these already. The case also involved a witness, during the course…

COUNTY COURT HAS POWER TO SET ASIDE A JUDGMENT AFTER TRIAL  - IF IT WAS OBTAINED BY FRAUD

COUNTY COURT HAS POWER TO SET ASIDE A JUDGMENT AFTER TRIAL – IF IT WAS OBTAINED BY FRAUD

December 18, 2017 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Setting aside judgment, Witness statements

The decision in Salekipour & Anor v Parmar [2017] EWCA Civ 2141 was made after three previous hearings a (including two appeal hearings) in the lower courts.  It was the only time the claimants were successful.  It involved an important procedural…

MAKE UP A FRAUDULENT CASE, TELL LIES TO THE COURT - GO TO JAIL: THE FORGED WILL CASE HAS A SEQUEL

MAKE UP A FRAUDULENT CASE, TELL LIES TO THE COURT – GO TO JAIL: THE FORGED WILL CASE HAS A SEQUEL

December 11, 2017 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Committal proceedings, Members Content, Witness statements

An earlier post looked at Patel -v- Patel [2017] EWHC 133 (Ch) in which the judge disbelieved all the witnesses who gave evidence that a will had been made in 2005. The trial judge observed. “My remaining concern with Nirja’s evidence is…

WITNESSES WHO ARGUE THE CASE AND EXPERTS WHO ACT AS ADVOCATES: THIS IS NOT GOING TO HELP ...

WITNESSES WHO ARGUE THE CASE AND EXPERTS WHO ACT AS ADVOCATES: THIS IS NOT GOING TO HELP …

December 10, 2017 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Credibility of experts, Expert evidence, Experts, Members Content, Witness statements

In  British Telecommunications Plc v Office Of Communications [2017] CAT 25 the Competition Appeal Tribunal commented on two of the central evidential issues of much commercial litigation: witnesses who give much commentary and “argue” the case; experts who act as advocates. …

PROVING THINGS 79: SOME THINGS JUST CAN'T BE A COINCIDENCE: A CAR CRASH OF A CASE

PROVING THINGS 79: SOME THINGS JUST CAN’T BE A COINCIDENCE: A CAR CRASH OF A CASE

December 7, 2017 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Applications, Civil evidence, Committal proceedings, Members Content, Witness statements

We have already looked today at the judgment in Liverpool Victoria Insurance Company Ltd v Yavuz & Ors[2017] EWHC 3088 (QB). However that judgment also contains a close and careful analysis of witness evidence. “I start by asking myself this question:…

SIGNING THE STATEMENT OF TRUTH IN PRE-ACTION DOCUMENTS: WILL THE SOLICITOR GO TO JAIL OR NOT?

SIGNING THE STATEMENT OF TRUTH IN PRE-ACTION DOCUMENTS: WILL THE SOLICITOR GO TO JAIL OR NOT?

December 7, 2017 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Applications, Committal proceedings, Members Content, Statements of Truth, Witness statements

There has already been some discussion in the Gazette about the judgment in Liverpool Victoria Insurance Company Ltd v Yavuz & Ors [2017] EWHC 3088 (QB). In particular the observations in relation to signature of documents by the legal representative. This…

PROVING THINGS 78: AN ABSENT WITNESS IS NEVER GOING TO HELP: DEFENDANT'S FAILURE TO TAKE CONTEMPORARY STATEMENTS LEADS TO ADVERSE INFERENCES

PROVING THINGS 78: AN ABSENT WITNESS IS NEVER GOING TO HELP: DEFENDANT’S FAILURE TO TAKE CONTEMPORARY STATEMENTS LEADS TO ADVERSE INFERENCES

December 5, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Clinical Negligence, Members Content, Uncategorized, Witness statements

In a talk today to a group of clinical negligence lawyers I discussed the issue of evidence, and “missing” documents and witnesses. In particular the relevance of   Keefe v Isle of Man Steam Packet Co Ltd [2010] EWCA Civ 683 on the…

PROVING THINGS 77: AN UNATTRACTIVE ARGUMENT: WHEN A PARTY HAS CAUSED AN ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE IT CANNOT BENEFIT FROM IT

PROVING THINGS 77: AN UNATTRACTIVE ARGUMENT: WHEN A PARTY HAS CAUSED AN ABSENCE OF EVIDENCE IT CANNOT BENEFIT FROM IT

December 3, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Clinical Negligence, Members Content, Witness statements

When a party has caused a gap in the evidence it is rarely open to that party to rely on the absence it has caused.  This was made clear by Mr Justice Foskett in JMX v Norfolk and Norwich Hospitals NHS…

LEGAL QUACKERY & AN "OVERWHELMING MIASMA OF FAKE LAW" : OBSTRUCTING JUSTICE AND OBSTRUCTING THE COURT SYSTEM

LEGAL QUACKERY & AN “OVERWHELMING MIASMA OF FAKE LAW” : OBSTRUCTING JUSTICE AND OBSTRUCTING THE COURT SYSTEM

November 29, 2017 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Access to justice, Members Content, Witness statements

I usually confine this blog to cases relating to the law in England and Wales. However the judgment of  Noonan J in Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Martin & anor [2017] IEHC 707 was brought to my attention by an…

FABRICATING DOCUMENTS AND MISLEADING THE JUDGES: WHEN KEY DOCUMENTS ARE HIDDEN BEHIND THE CURTAINS IN COURT

FABRICATING DOCUMENTS AND MISLEADING THE JUDGES: WHEN KEY DOCUMENTS ARE HIDDEN BEHIND THE CURTAINS IN COURT

November 27, 2017 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Disclosure, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment of Mr Justice Henry Carr in Ghassemian v Chatsworth Court Freehold Company Ltd & Ors [2016] EWHC 872 (Ch) illustrates the lengths to which some litigants will go. The judge found that the applicant had forged documents, backdated applications…

HOW MANY LITIGANTS HAVE REGRETTED STARTING THE CASE? POISE AND POLISH IS NEVER ENOUGH IN A COURT ROOM

HOW MANY LITIGANTS HAVE REGRETTED STARTING THE CASE? POISE AND POLISH IS NEVER ENOUGH IN A COURT ROOM

November 25, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

This one paragraph from a judgement yesterday gives pause for thought. “The Claimant observed somewhat wistfully towards the conclusion of the trial that had he anticipated what was entailed, he would not have brought this claim in the first place….

WITNESS CREDIBILITY, VERY BAD SINGING AND A MOVIE: ALL HUMAN LIFE IS HERE: (SOMETHING FOR LAWYERS TOO...)

WITNESS CREDIBILITY, VERY BAD SINGING AND A MOVIE: ALL HUMAN LIFE IS HERE: (SOMETHING FOR LAWYERS TOO…)

November 22, 2017 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

The decision in Martin & Anor v Kogan & Ors [2017] EWHC 2927 (IPEC) centred on witness credibility. Not so much honesty but accuracy of recollection. It illustrates the issue of how the judge goes about assessing evidence when witnesses…

THE HIPPOCRATIC OATH AND LEGAL HYPOCRISY: WHAT WE CAN LEARN FROM DOCTORS?

THE HIPPOCRATIC OATH AND LEGAL HYPOCRISY: WHAT WE CAN LEARN FROM DOCTORS?

November 20, 2017 · by gexall · in Amendment, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Clinical Negligence, Limitation, Members Content, Uncategorized, Witness statements

Lawyers, particularly litigators, are infinitely wise.  This is because we specialise in hindsight: “Why didn’t you do that?” ; “You should have done that”; “Why wasn’t that written down?”  This is particularly acute in clinical negligence cases where one profession…

APPEALS ON FACTS AND WITNESS EVIDENCE: DAMNED IF THE WITNESSES AGREE: DAMNED IF THEY DON'T

APPEALS ON FACTS AND WITNESS EVIDENCE: DAMNED IF THE WITNESSES AGREE: DAMNED IF THEY DON’T

November 18, 2017 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment of the Court of Appeal in Shittu v The Home Office [2017] EWCA Civ 1748 contains some interesting observations about attempts to appeal on findings of fact, “judgecraft” and fact-finding generally.   “The case followed the pattern of many…

WHY DIDN'T YOU TELL ME THAT BEFORE WE WENT INTO COURT?  THINGS LAWYERS LEARN HALF WAY THROUGH A TRIAL

WHY DIDN’T YOU TELL ME THAT BEFORE WE WENT INTO COURT? THINGS LAWYERS LEARN HALF WAY THROUGH A TRIAL

November 9, 2017 · by gexall · in Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

The post earlier today on a case where key facts came to light on the third day of a trial led me to ask lawyers if they had similar experiences.  That sudden, and unexpected, “surprise” bit of evidence which no-one…

THE THINGS YOU FIND OUT HALF WAY THROUGH A TRIAL...  A CASE VERY MUCH TO POINT

THE THINGS YOU FIND OUT HALF WAY THROUGH A TRIAL… A CASE VERY MUCH TO POINT

November 9, 2017 · by gexall · in Applications, Case Management, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

The case of Jollah, R (On the Application Of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department (No. 2) [2017] EWHC 2821 (Admin) makes fascinating reading. It is an object lesson in the need to ask searching questions when representing a…

WHO WAS TELLING THE TRUTH? BOUDICCA, POSSESSORY TITLE AND THE JUDGE'S ROLE AS FACT FINDER: "DETERMINED COMPETITORS IN AN IMPLAUSIBILITY CONTEST"

WHO WAS TELLING THE TRUTH? BOUDICCA, POSSESSORY TITLE AND THE JUDGE’S ROLE AS FACT FINDER: “DETERMINED COMPETITORS IN AN IMPLAUSIBILITY CONTEST”

November 9, 2017 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In McClelland v Elvin & Ors [2017] EWHC 2795 (QB) Mr Justice Turner considered an appeal where the trial judge had found against a party claiming adverse possession. There are some interesting observations in relation to Roman Britain, grounds of…

BLACKPOOL CASE SHOWS THAT MEMORY IS NOT A ROCK - IT DEGRADES OVER TIME: "EMBELLISHMENT" OF A WITNESS STATEMENT RARELY HELPS

BLACKPOOL CASE SHOWS THAT MEMORY IS NOT A ROCK – IT DEGRADES OVER TIME: “EMBELLISHMENT” OF A WITNESS STATEMENT RARELY HELPS

November 7, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

There have been 398 people who have looked at this blog directly from a link at Fansonline.net. This has little to do with the intrinsic fascination that football fans obviously have for civil procedure. It is more do do with…

PRACTISING "DEFENSIVE LITIGATION" : ESSENTIAL CHECKLISTS GATHERED TOGETHER

PRACTISING “DEFENSIVE LITIGATION” : ESSENTIAL CHECKLISTS GATHERED TOGETHER

November 2, 2017 · by gexall · in Avoiding negligence claims, Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Costs, Costs budgeting, Members Content, Witness statements

What many (if not most) of the posts on this blog make clear is that there is now precious little room for error in civil procedure.  To operate effectively, and profitably, we have to develop systems of “defensive litigation”. That…

APPEALING FINDINGS OF FACT: AN UNUSUAL ARGUMENT - TO NO AVAIL

APPEALING FINDINGS OF FACT: AN UNUSUAL ARGUMENT – TO NO AVAIL

November 1, 2017 · by gexall · in Appeals, Members Content, Witness statements

In Bedford County Council v GE (Eritrea) [2017] EWCA Civ 1521 the appellant attempted to argue that the trial judge had erred on the facts.  The arguments were given fairly short shrift. THE CASE After a hearing in the Court of…

PROVING THINGS 69: SOLICITORS EVIDENCE OF (THEIR OWN) LOSS "WHOLLY INADEQUATE": IMPORTANT POINTS ABOUT DELAY TOO

PROVING THINGS 69: SOLICITORS EVIDENCE OF (THEIR OWN) LOSS “WHOLLY INADEQUATE”: IMPORTANT POINTS ABOUT DELAY TOO

October 31, 2017 · by gexall · in Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Damages, Members Content, Witness statements

This blog often reports on cases where a party fails to appreciate the scope and depth of evidence needed to prove a claim for damages. This issue arose in the judgment today in  Hersi & Co Solicitors, R (On the Application…

ANOTHER SORRY TALE - FORGING SIGNATURES ON WITNESS STATEMENTS:  A "PRECEDENT" WITNESS STATEMENT CAN RARELY BE A GOOD THING

ANOTHER SORRY TALE – FORGING SIGNATURES ON WITNESS STATEMENTS: A “PRECEDENT” WITNESS STATEMENT CAN RARELY BE A GOOD THING

October 24, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

The Law Society Gazette carries an account of a solicitor struck off for “forging” the signature on witness statements.  I want to concentrate on the way that the witness statements themselves were produced. This was not dishonest but is worrying….

BEING A WITNESS IN COURT:  "AVOIDING HUMILIATION":  USEFUL LINKS (VIDEOS TOO)

BEING A WITNESS IN COURT: “AVOIDING HUMILIATION”: USEFUL LINKS (VIDEOS TOO)

October 23, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Useful links, Witness statements

This idea for this post comes from another blog. Pink Tape has a recent post giving  parents tips on giving evidence in court.  This caused me to look at the assistance available generally. This is one part of the legal…

A LESSON FOR ANYONE DRAFTING WITNESS STATEMENTS: GO ON - HAVE A BIT OF A DIG: WHAT CAN POSSIBLY GO WRONG?

A LESSON FOR ANYONE DRAFTING WITNESS STATEMENTS: GO ON – HAVE A BIT OF A DIG: WHAT CAN POSSIBLY GO WRONG?

October 22, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment of Mr Justice Fraser in Riva Properties Ltd & Ors v Foster + Partners Ltd [2017] EWHC 2574 (TCC) contains further examples of the dangers of making comments in witness statements. A witness statement is for facts, comments and stage…

ATTACKING THE OTHER SIDE'S CREDIBILITY: DEFENDANTS ARE THE ARCHITECTS OF THEIR OWN DOWNFALL: SELF-SERVING STATEMENTS ARE TO NO AVAIL

ATTACKING THE OTHER SIDE’S CREDIBILITY: DEFENDANTS ARE THE ARCHITECTS OF THEIR OWN DOWNFALL: SELF-SERVING STATEMENTS ARE TO NO AVAIL

October 19, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

There are a lot of reasons why litigators should read the judgment of Mr Justice Fraser in  Riva Properties Ltd & Ors v Foster + Partners Ltd [2017] EWHC 2574 (TCC).  Not least is the judge’s assessment of the witness evidence…

THE CIVIL STANDARD OF PROOF AND ALLEGATIONS OF DISHONESTY: AVOIDING HINDSIGHT

THE CIVIL STANDARD OF PROOF AND ALLEGATIONS OF DISHONESTY: AVOIDING HINDSIGHT

October 6, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In Group Seven Ltd & Anor v Nasir & Ors [2017] EWHC 2466 (Ch) Mr Justice Morgan considered issues relating to the standard of proof when there are allegations of dishonesty and fraud.  Part of the judgment also deals with the…

WITNESSES, SURVEILLANCE, DEMEANOUR AND EXPERTS - IT ALL COMES DOWN TO CREDIBILITY: A  PERFORMER UNLIKELY TO FOOL ALL OF THE PEOPLE ALL OF THE TIME

WITNESSES, SURVEILLANCE, DEMEANOUR AND EXPERTS – IT ALL COMES DOWN TO CREDIBILITY: A PERFORMER UNLIKELY TO FOOL ALL OF THE PEOPLE ALL OF THE TIME

October 4, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

We have already looked at judge’s observations as to the amount of material before the court in the case of  Miley v Friends Life Ltd [2017] EWHC 2415 (QB). It was a case that rested upon credibility. Surveillance evidence, expert evidence and…

SOME WARNINGS AS TO EVIDENCE: A SYMPHONY REVIVED:  HOW THE JUDGE CONDUCTS AN ASSESSMENT OF CREDIBILITY

SOME WARNINGS AS TO EVIDENCE: A SYMPHONY REVIVED: HOW THE JUDGE CONDUCTS AN ASSESSMENT OF CREDIBILITY

September 29, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Experts, Members Content, Witness statements

The post yesterday on witness credibility in the case of Frenkel v Lyampert & Ors [2017] EWHC 2223 (Ch) referred to a passage in the earlier case of EPI Environmental Technologies Inc v Symphony Plastic Technologies plc (Practice Note) [2005] 1 WLR 3456.    This…

ASSESSING THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: PROBLEMS WITH INDEPENDENCE WHEN THE WITNESS REQUIRES A TRANSLATOR

ASSESSING THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: PROBLEMS WITH INDEPENDENCE WHEN THE WITNESS REQUIRES A TRANSLATOR

September 28, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

Who is going to be believed? This is the central question in many (if not most) cases that go to trial.  The judgment of Miss Amanda Tipples QC in Frenkel v Lyampert & Ors [2017] EWHC 2223 (Ch) shows many of…

SIGNING A STATEMENT OF TRUTH ON BEHALF OF A CLIENT: A STARK REMINDER FROM THE COUNTY COURT ONLINE PILOT PRACTICE DIRECTION

SIGNING A STATEMENT OF TRUTH ON BEHALF OF A CLIENT: A STARK REMINDER FROM THE COUNTY COURT ONLINE PILOT PRACTICE DIRECTION

September 26, 2017 · by gexall · in Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Members Content, Statements of Case, Statements of Truth, Witness statements

I have looked before at the issues that arise when the legal representative signs a statement of truth on behalf of a client.  These issues are shown in stark terms in the Practice Direction 51S – The County Court Online…

PROVING THINGS 67: THE DIFFICULTIES WHEN WITNESSES DEPARTS FROM THEIR WITNESS STATEMENT: MULTIPLE INCONSISTENCIES DAMAGE CREDIBILITY

PROVING THINGS 67: THE DIFFICULTIES WHEN WITNESSES DEPARTS FROM THEIR WITNESS STATEMENT: MULTIPLE INCONSISTENCIES DAMAGE CREDIBILITY

September 19, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

I am grateful to my colleague Colm Nugent for sending me a copy of the decision in Baker -v- British Gas Services (Commercial) Limited [2017] EWHC 2302. Amanda Yip QC (sitting as a Deputy Judge of the High Court*), considered…

FACT FINDING FOR LAWYERS : HOLIDAY CLAIMS: SRA GUIDANCE - NOT A WALK ON THE BEACH

FACT FINDING FOR LAWYERS : HOLIDAY CLAIMS: SRA GUIDANCE – NOT A WALK ON THE BEACH

September 8, 2017 · by gexall · in Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

The Solicitors Regulation Authority has issued a specific warning notice in relation to holiday sickness claims.  The notice, issued on the 6th September 2017, contains important guidance in relation to the role of the solicitor in investigating facts. The guidance…

WITNESSES, STATEMENTS AND LAWYERS -  "SELF PROTECTION": A QUICK RECAP

WITNESSES, STATEMENTS AND LAWYERS – “SELF PROTECTION”: A QUICK RECAP

September 6, 2017 · by gexall · in Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

Sometimes, quite often in fact, clients need “protecting” from lawyers who are preparing witness statements on their behalf. I have dealt with this in previous posts and will write on this again in the near future. However here I want…

THROWING EVERYTHING IN AT TRIAL- INCLUDING THE KITCHEN CABINET: YOU HAVE TO PUT YOUR CASE (AND PLEAD IT)

THROWING EVERYTHING IN AT TRIAL- INCLUDING THE KITCHEN CABINET: YOU HAVE TO PUT YOUR CASE (AND PLEAD IT)

August 28, 2017 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Members Content, Statements of Case, Witness statements

There are some important observations in the judgment of Mr Justice Henry Carr in Neptune (Europe) Ltd v Devol Kitchens Ltd [2017] EWHC 2172 (Pat) about the need to plead and put a case at trial.  An attempt to introduce a…

PROVING THINGS 66: IT ALL COMES DOWN TO THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: WHERE THERE'S A WILL THERE'S A WAY

PROVING THINGS 66: IT ALL COMES DOWN TO THE CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES: WHERE THERE’S A WILL THERE’S A WAY

August 22, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

This blog regularly looks at cases in which trial judges assess the credibility of witnesses. Here I want to look at the careful analysis of witness evidence by HHJ Paul Matthews (sitting as a High Court judge)  in Legg & Anor…

WITNESS STATEMENTS "INADMISSIBLE":  CONTAINED "SUBJECTIVE INTENTION", "OPINION" AND "LEGAL ARGUMENT":  ANOTHER EXAMPLE

WITNESS STATEMENTS “INADMISSIBLE”: CONTAINED “SUBJECTIVE INTENTION”, “OPINION” AND “LEGAL ARGUMENT”: ANOTHER EXAMPLE

August 22, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

A brief passage under the judgment of Mr Justice Arnold in Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Ltd v Fougera Sweden Holding 2 AB [2017] EWHC 1995 (Ch) serves to show how much “witness evidence” served by a litigant can, in fact, be inadmissible….

WITNESS EVIDENCE: THE DANGERS OF OPINION EVIDENCE  AND TRYING TO USURP THE ROLE OF THE JUDGE : BACK TO MARSH -v- MINISTRY OF DEFENCE

WITNESS EVIDENCE: THE DANGERS OF OPINION EVIDENCE AND TRYING TO USURP THE ROLE OF THE JUDGE : BACK TO MARSH -v- MINISTRY OF DEFENCE

August 20, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

Anyone considering matters relating to witness evidence and the drafting of statements will be drawn like a moth to the fire to the decision of Lady Justice Thirwall in Marsh -v- Ministry of Justice [2017] EWHC 1040. Once again I am returning…

THE DUTY TO PUT YOUR CASE : FINDINGS MADE ON KEY POINTS  WHICH WERE NOT PUT TO THE WITNESS  OVERTURNED ON APPEAL

THE DUTY TO PUT YOUR CASE : FINDINGS MADE ON KEY POINTS WHICH WERE NOT PUT TO THE WITNESS OVERTURNED ON APPEAL

August 18, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In Chen v Ng (British Virgin Islands) [2017] UKPC 27  the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council considered the extent of the duty to put a case to a witness. It is a reminder of the importance of putting a case…

DEFENDANT DEBARRED FROM CALLING WITNESS EVIDENCE AT TRIAL: COURT OF APPEAL OVERTURNS FINDING FOR DEFENDANT

August 17, 2017 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Witness statements

The case of Durrant -v- Chief Constable of Avon & Somerset Constabulary is a long-running saga. We have looked at it twice before. The incident occurred in 2009.  In 2013 the Court of Appeal overturned a judge’s decision to grant…

"MUST" MEANS "MUST": WHEN  CRUCIAL PARTS OF YOUR EVIDENCE AMOUNTS TO NO MORE THAN GOSSIP AND RUMOUR IT CAN BE COSTLY.

“MUST” MEANS “MUST”: WHEN CRUCIAL PARTS OF YOUR EVIDENCE AMOUNTS TO NO MORE THAN GOSSIP AND RUMOUR IT CAN BE COSTLY.

August 2, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

I have already written that there are many reasons litigators should read the judgment of Lady Justice Thirwall in Marsh -v- Ministry of Justice [2017] EWHC 1040 (QB) (the subsequent judgment on costs is also worth reading and will be covered soon)….

A MATTER OF EVIDENCE AND A MATTER OF FACT: CLINICAL NEGLIGENCE ACTION WITH "AN OBVIOUS LACUNA IN THE DEFENDANT'S CASE"

A MATTER OF EVIDENCE AND A MATTER OF FACT: CLINICAL NEGLIGENCE ACTION WITH “AN OBVIOUS LACUNA IN THE DEFENDANT’S CASE”

August 2, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Clinical Negligence, Members Content, Witness statements

Last year I wrote a series of posts about the seminal case of Whitehouse -v- Jordan. The aim was to point out that the essence of the decision was about findings of fact not legal principle.  The House of Lords upheld…

MEMORIES, WITNESS STATEMENTS AND EVIDENCE: A SCIENTIFIC VIEW: WHAT EXPERTS WISH YOU KNEW

MEMORIES, WITNESS STATEMENTS AND EVIDENCE: A SCIENTIFIC VIEW: WHAT EXPERTS WISH YOU KNEW

July 30, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

I have written before about the issue of memory and witness evidence.  I have also written about the work of  Dr Julia Shaw on this subject.  More guidance can be found in her article in the Scientific American  What Experts…

WITNESS STATEMENTS DIRECT: MEMORY, GESTMIN £15 MILLION AND QUITE A LOT OF ALCOHOL: A HEADY BREW

WITNESS STATEMENTS DIRECT: MEMORY, GESTMIN £15 MILLION AND QUITE A LOT OF ALCOHOL: A HEADY BREW

July 27, 2017 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

There is a certain appropriateness in one of the last major first-instance judgments of Mr Justice Leggatt being about witness credibility and the Gestmin criteria. In Blue -v- Ashley [2017] EWHC 1928 (Comm) Gestmin figured heavily. Everyone believed they were…

← Previous 1 … 16 17 18 … 26 Next →

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Subscription notifies you of a new post, it does not give you access to members' content.

Join 12.4K other subscribers

Recent Posts

  • LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 5: DEFENDING A CLAIM BASED ON A COUNTERFACTUAL — 10 KEY POINTS FOR DEFENDANTS
  • LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 4 : PLEADING AND PROVING THE COUNTERFACTUAL: 10 KEY POINTS FOR CLAIMANTS
  • WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: RECOLLECTION OF MEETINGS TWO YEARS EARLIER IS LIKELY TO BE IMPERFECT: THE FACT THAT THE CLAIMANT’S WITNESSES “SETTLED ON A CONCLUSION THAT EXACTLY ACCORDS WITH THE CLAIMANT’S COMMERCIAL INTERESTS IS UNSURPRISING” BUT NEEDS TO BE “TREATED WITH CAUTION”
  • PROVING THINGS 307: FAILING TO PROVE THE COUNTERFACTUAL: THE CLAIMANTS ESTABLISHED NEGLIGENCE BUT FAILED TO PROVE WHAT THEY WOULD HAVE DONE IF GIVEN THE CORRECT ADVICE
  • ENFORCEMENT BULLETIN No. 8: THE BANK GETS ITS CARS BACK: SUMMARY JUDGMENT, UNDISCLOSED COMMISSIONS AND THE IMPORTANCE OF PLEADING A DEFENCE THAT CAN ACTUALLY DEFEAT THE CLAIM

Top Posts

YOU CAN'T SIMPLY WITHDRAW AN APPEAL WITHOUT PERMISSION: APPELLANT SEEKS TO WITHDRAW APPEAL & DOESN'T ATTEND - BUT THE APPEAL GOES AHEAD AND THE APPELLANT WINS ...
COSTS BITES 459: A SUCCESSFUL CLAIMANT SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DEPRIVED OF THEIR COSTS BECAUSE PRECEDENT U WAS SERVED FIVE HOURS LATE
A PRACTICAL AI PRIMER FOR LAWYERS: THE SECOND EDITION OF "ANDREW AND THE MARVELLOUS ANALYTICAL ENGINE": MAJOR ADDITIONS TO A FAST MOVING AND IMPORTANT AREA
COST BITES 459: YOU CAN SPEND £1 MILLION ON COSTS, ESSENTIALLY "WIN" THE CASE BUT STILL NOT RECOVER THE COSTS: HIGH COURT CONSIDERS APPEAL IN A VERY EXPENSIVE BOUNDARY DISPUTE
COSTS BITES 461: THE £14,113 BILL THAT BECAME A £58,543 DEBT (PLUS INTEREST...): COSTS WERE HIGH "IN LARGE PART, THAT APPEARS TO BE AS A RESULT OF THE EXTRA WORK REQUIRED TO ADDRESS THE DEFENDANT'S UNMERITORIOUS AND WIDE-RANGING SUBMISSIONS"

Archives

Blogroll

  • Fatal Accident Law
  • Legal Futures
  • Personal injury: Liability and Damages

Books

  • Munkman & Exall on Damages for Personal Injuries and Death 15th ed
  • The APIL Guide to Fatal Accidents 4th edition

Useful Links

  • Buntools (for preparing PDF Bundles)
  • Kings Chambers
  • Kings Chambers Costs & Litigation Funding
  • Kings Chambers Serious Injury
  • The Civil Procedure Rules
  • The Law Society Gazette
  • The National Archives Recently Published Judgments
  • The Senior Court Costs Office Guide 2025
  • www.Bailii.org

Copyright

© Gordon Exall, Exall Legal Training, Civil Litigation Brief, 2013-2026. Unauthorised use and or duplication of the material contained on this blog without permission is strictly prohibited.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.

To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Membership Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertising Policy
  • Copyright
  • Legal Disclaimer

Copyright © 2026 Civil Litigation Brief ®

Powered by Big Yellow Workshop

Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.