BOOK REVIEW : O’HARE & BROWNE CIVIL LITIGATION (22nd EDITION): HONESTLY HOW DO YOU MANAGE WITHOUT IT…

I am, if truth be known, in awe of this book. Its earlier editions were a major help when I first learnt about civil procedure as a student on the Law Society Finals course (it was then known as O’Hare & Hill). It was even more help when I was training and then qualified as a solicitor.  It remains highly useful in my daily work at the Bar.  So I review it with some trepidation.   My attention was caught by the author’s observations in the preface, looking backwards, to the future and pointing out some of the stark inadequacies of the current system.

THE AUTHORS

John O’Hare is a retired Master of the Senior Costs Office. Kevin Browne is an Associate Professor of the University of Law, London.

THE BOOK IS UNDOUBTEDLY COMPREHENSIVE

One of its strengths is the breadth of its coverage. Starting with an outline of the civil court system and then visiting all points between, including costs, enforcement and ending with appeals to the Supreme Court.   This breadth of material does not lead to any lack of detail. The book remains readable to the student and practitioner alike.

WHAT DOES THE FUTURE HOLD FOR CIVIL LITIGATION?  SOME AWKARD HOME TRUTHS

The Preface is well worth reading.  It looks back at the history and texts of civil procedure but also looks forward.

“This book has been in print now for over 46 years. We have sometimes wondered how long it will last…Developments in digitalisation and also quantum leaps in AI will soon utterly change the shape of court based civil disputes law.”

The digital future

“Turning to the immediate future, we believe that we are now quite close to a time in which, if both sides are represented, all proceedings will be issued online, notifications online will replace service and, in most cases, all pre-trial hearings will be conducted online or by telephone. Litigants in person who do not have access to a smartphone or laptop will have to deliver paperwork to the court office for it to upload.”

Thing have got a lot worse

“Since our last edition was published, the County Court has become more remote from its users and the volume and scale of court inefficiencies has increased. The Civil National Business Centre (CNBC) was set up in 2023 as part of the centralisation of civil justice operations. It has had a ‘devastating impact’ on justice and has caused ‘debilitating delays for all parties’. The words just quoted come from a Parliamentary report published in 2025 (see the Law Society Gazette report County court centralisation a disaster, MPs say in coruscating report on ‘Cinderella service’). Today, most County Court cases are commenced online or by sending papers by post to the CNBC, an office which is frighteningly understaffed. Papers get lost. Persons who telephone the CNBC to find out what is happening often have to wait hours to get through and, once a mistake is made, it can be difficult to get it corrected. In addition to inconvenience and vexation, parties may also suffer something worse: exposure to malign people intent on committing fraud”

SCAMMERS ARE OUT THERE

The  introduction  points out that the ” CNBC website displays this message:-

“Scammers are mimicking genuine HMCTS phone numbers and email addresses. They may demand payment and claim to be from HMRC or enforcement. If you’re unsure, do not pay anything and report the scam to Action Fraud.”

It reminds of the case of Associated Installations Ltd v All Asbestos Ltd [2025] EWCC 76, (which we looked at here) where scammers posing as enforcement agents conned £45,549 out of a judgment debtor.

This is one of many pitfalls for the less computer (and fraud) savvy litigant.

BACK TO THE BOOK: THE CIVIL LITIGATION BRIEF TEST FOR BOOKS

1. Should you buy it?

For once I would go further.  It is silly to be without it. In this digital age it is useful, if not essential, not to have a book like this within easy reach.

2. Is it value for money?

At £130.00 it is less than half of the court fee alone for making an application if you ever have to put things right. Of course it is value for money.

3. Where can I buy it?

Here. 

ONE OF MY FAVOURITE STORIES RELATING TO THIS BOOK

This story underlies the book’s ongoing practicality. For many years the book as known as O’Hare and Hill.  The then co-author Robert Hill was a local District Judge and I got to know him very well over the years.  The book had a section on evidence and the importance of ensuring evidence was removed from court after the trial. It recounted an experience of a young solicitor who arranged for parts of heavy farming plant to be taken to court as evidence in a trial. It had to be kept outside.  The same solicitor returned to the court several years later to find the plant still in the courtyard of the court, but painted so as to match the court’s external colour scheme.  I asked Robert about this and he confessed “That was me”.  I left it in the grounds of Exeter Castle” (which then contained the county court). “To be honest, its probably still there now…”

That illustrates the practical nature of the book, it contains sage advice in addition to setting out the rules and cases. (If anyone is passing Exeter Castle let us know if there is still agricultural machinery outside…”