Civil Litigation Brief ®
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Membership Plans
  • Webinars
  • Login
Updates and Commentary on Civil Procedure, by Gordon Exall, Barrister, Kings Chambers
Browse: Home » Witness statements » Page 15
CROSS-EXAMINATION: THE DUTY TO PUT A CASE: A GEM OF A DECISION

CROSS-EXAMINATION: THE DUTY TO PUT A CASE: A GEM OF A DECISION

November 29, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

In W Nagel (A Firm) v Pluczenik Diamond Company NV [2018] EWCA Civ 2640 the Court of Appeal made an important observation about the duty of a cross-examiner to put their client’s case to an opposing witness. This provides an opportunity…

GOOD IDEAS FROM WESTERN AUSTRALIA: WITNESS STATEMENTS, COMMUNICATIONS AND CONFINING THE ISSUES IN DISPUTE IN CIVIL LITIGATION

GOOD IDEAS FROM WESTERN AUSTRALIA: WITNESS STATEMENTS, COMMUNICATIONS AND CONFINING THE ISSUES IN DISPUTE IN CIVIL LITIGATION

November 27, 2018 · by gexall · in Advocacy, Members Content, Useful links, Witness statements, Written advocacy

A while back I wrote a post pointing out guidance on drafting witness statements given by the Western Australian Bar Association.  I am grateful to Australian barrister David Laws for pointing out the new site where this guidance can be…

A HAPPY READER WRITES: WHEN BLOG POSTS ARE READ A ZILLION TIMES...

A HAPPY READER WRITES: WHEN BLOG POSTS ARE READ A ZILLION TIMES…

November 24, 2018 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

a As a blogger feedback comes in many forms.  Yesterday I had an email from a litigant in person.  The method described may well become more prevalent. THE EMAIL “Mr Exall, I wrote to you this time last year with…

LINKS TO GUIDANCE ON DRAFTING WITNESS STATEMENT: INTERACTIVE BLOGGING

LINKS TO GUIDANCE ON DRAFTING WITNESS STATEMENT: INTERACTIVE BLOGGING

November 22, 2018 · by gexall · in Advocacy, Fatal Accidents, Members Content, Witness statements

Yesterday I was speaking on the APIL Fatal Accidents course. One of the points I was making was the importance of reading the rules and and guidance in relation to the drafting of witness statements.   The delegates asked for links…

SURVEY ON WITNESS STATEMENTS: WORKING PARTY SURVEY:  A REMINDER OF PAST COMMENTS ... SOME CHESTNUTS HERE

SURVEY ON WITNESS STATEMENTS: WORKING PARTY SURVEY: A REMINDER OF PAST COMMENTS … SOME CHESTNUTS HERE

November 16, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Useful links, Witness statements

The Witness Evidence Working Group is carrying out a survey of the use of witness statements in the Business & Property Courts.  Here I provide a link to the post and a reminder of the comments that some judges have…

APPLYING FOR RELIEF FROM SANCTIONS: 14 KEY POINTS TO HELP EASE THE STRAIN

APPLYING FOR RELIEF FROM SANCTIONS: 14 KEY POINTS TO HELP EASE THE STRAIN

November 15, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Avoiding negligence claims, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Witness statements

There was a nice tweet earlier today from pupil barrister Miranda Grell explaining she had just appeared in her first relief from sanctions application and had found this blog useful.  This reminded me that it may be a good time…

YOU'RE FIRED: A LITIGATOR ON THE APPRENTICE 8: "THE BIGGEST ATTEMPT AT ROBBERY SINCE HATTON GARDEN": DID OUR LAWYER GET THEIR HANDS DIRTY?

YOU’RE FIRED: A LITIGATOR ON THE APPRENTICE 8: “THE BIGGEST ATTEMPT AT ROBBERY SINCE HATTON GARDEN”: DID OUR LAWYER GET THEIR HANDS DIRTY?

November 14, 2018 · by gexall · in Fork handles, Fundamental Dishonesty, Members Content, Witness statements

We have one surviving lawyer – Sarah Ann. This week she switched teams – to “Collaborative” and turned her hand to garden design, even getting her hands dirty in the process. Her team won.  This series continues for another week….

PROVING THINGS 133: FALLING OFF A BED AND THE PIECES OF THE JIGSAW

PROVING THINGS 133: FALLING OFF A BED AND THE PIECES OF THE JIGSAW

November 14, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Personal Injury, Witness statements

The case of Busby v Berkshire Bed Company Ltd [2018] EWHC 2976 (QB) was one of those cases that centred on credible evidence. It is an example of where witnesses can be totally honest but mistaken in their recollection. The judge…

THE DANGERS OF BEING "BULLISH" ON PROCEDURAL ISSUES: APPLICATION DISMISSED (AND IT TOOK TOO LONG)

THE DANGERS OF BEING “BULLISH” ON PROCEDURAL ISSUES: APPLICATION DISMISSED (AND IT TOOK TOO LONG)

November 13, 2018 · by gexall · in Abuse of Process, Applications, Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Striking out, Witness statements

In Red Bull GmbH v Big Horn UK Ltd & Ors [2018] EWHC 2794 (Ch) Master Clark completed the judgment”I conclude by noting the regrettable extent to which this judgment has been lengthened by the determination of the procedural points of…

PROVING THINGS 132: BUNDLES, BURDENS OF PROOF AND GO-KARTS: CLAIMANT MANAGES TO CROSS THE WINNING LINE ON APPEAL

PROVING THINGS 132: BUNDLES, BURDENS OF PROOF AND GO-KARTS: CLAIMANT MANAGES TO CROSS THE WINNING LINE ON APPEAL

November 8, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment in Cowley Property Investment Ltd v Oxford Karting Ltd [2018] EWHC 2824 (Ch) contains a consideration of the rule that documents in an agreed trial bundle are admissible. It is a case all about proving things without calling evidence….

WHEN WITNESSES DIDN'T KNOW WHAT THEY WERE SAYING: WHY THE SOURCE OF INFORMATION AND BELIEF IS IMPORTANT

WHEN WITNESSES DIDN’T KNOW WHAT THEY WERE SAYING: WHY THE SOURCE OF INFORMATION AND BELIEF IS IMPORTANT

November 8, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

There is a short passage in the judgment in GPP Big Field LLP & Anor v Solar EPC Solutions SL [2018] EWHC 2866 (Comm) that shows (not for the first time this year) that those responsible for drafting witness statements often…

RESPONDENTS ALLOWED TO COMMENT AT HEARING : NEVERTHELESS SURVIVES A COSTS ORDER ON APPEAL

RESPONDENTS ALLOWED TO COMMENT AT HEARING : NEVERTHELESS SURVIVES A COSTS ORDER ON APPEAL

November 5, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Costs, Members Content, Witness statements

In  Bhogal & Anor v Knight [2018] EWHC 2952 (Ch) the appellants failed in their appeal following an order that the respondent pay the costs of their initial application. The procedure described in the judgment is instructive.  It was yet another…

REVEALING THE TRUE IDENTITY OF A WITNESS IN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS: APPLICATION FOR ANONYMITY SCUTTLED

REVEALING THE TRUE IDENTITY OF A WITNESS IN CIVIL PROCEEDINGS: APPLICATION FOR ANONYMITY SCUTTLED

November 5, 2018 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

In the judgment today in  Suez Fortune Investments Ltd & Anor v Talbot Underwriting Ltd & Ors [2018] EWHC 2929 (Comm) Mr Justice Teare allowed an application by the defendants that the true identity of a witness be disclosed.  The witness…

EXTENSIVE WITNESS EVIDENCE THAT WAS OF NO USE: A COMMON FINDING

EXTENSIVE WITNESS EVIDENCE THAT WAS OF NO USE: A COMMON FINDING

November 4, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Risks of litigation, Witness statements

We have already looked at the judgment of Mrs Justice Cockerill in  Recovery Partners GP Ltd & Anor v Rukhadze & Ors [2018] EWHC 2918 (Comm). It is worth looking at what the judge had to say about the witness evidence before…

THE STATEMENT OF TRUTH: WHY YOU AND YOUR CLIENTS NEED REGULAR REMINDERS OF THE RULES & CASES

THE STATEMENT OF TRUTH: WHY YOU AND YOUR CLIENTS NEED REGULAR REMINDERS OF THE RULES & CASES

November 2, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In Recovery Partners GP Ltd & Anor v Rukhadze & Ors [2018] EWHC 2918 (Comm) Mrs Justice Cockerill made some important observations that apply to every aspect of litigation.  We looked at the case yesterday: a stark reminder was provided of the dangers…

THE STATEMENT OF TRUTH: THE COURTS SAY IT AGAIN - NOT TO BE TAKEN LIGHTLY

THE STATEMENT OF TRUTH: THE COURTS SAY IT AGAIN – NOT TO BE TAKEN LIGHTLY

November 1, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In Recovery Partners GP Ltd & Anor v Rukhadze & Ors [2018] EWHC 2918 (Comm) Mrs Justice Cockerill provides a clear and stark reminder of the significance of the statement of truth and need for all relevant parties to sign it….

WITNESS STATEMENTS AND SOURCES OF INFORMATION AND BELIEF: 10 KEY POINTS THAT LITIGATORS SHOULD KNOW: A JUDGE MAKE GET A BIT IRKED IF YOU TRY TO USURP THEIR ROLE

WITNESS STATEMENTS AND SOURCES OF INFORMATION AND BELIEF: 10 KEY POINTS THAT LITIGATORS SHOULD KNOW: A JUDGE MAKE GET A BIT IRKED IF YOU TRY TO USURP THEIR ROLE

October 31, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

The post earlier today on the deficiencies in a witness statement  that led to it being excluded provides a good opportunity to reprise certain key points.  Not only was the excluded statement essentially “commentary” and “opinion” it also failed to…

WITNESS STATEMENT EXCLUDED BECAUSE IT WAS OF NO USE: THE DANGERS OF NOT KNOWING THE RULES RELATING TO WITNESS EVIDENCE

WITNESS STATEMENT EXCLUDED BECAUSE IT WAS OF NO USE: THE DANGERS OF NOT KNOWING THE RULES RELATING TO WITNESS EVIDENCE

October 31, 2018 · by gexall · in Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

I have noted, many times, on this blog the dangerous tendency of some practitioners to conflate witness statements with submissions.  Witness statements express opinions, comments on documents and the law and do not give the source of information and belief. …

TRYING TO SNEAK EXPERT EVIDENCE INTO A WITNESS STATEMENT: PEOPLE MIGHT NOTICE: DEFENDANT'S ATTEMPT TO EXHIBIT EXPERTS STRUCK OUT

TRYING TO SNEAK EXPERT EVIDENCE INTO A WITNESS STATEMENT: PEOPLE MIGHT NOTICE: DEFENDANT’S ATTEMPT TO EXHIBIT EXPERTS STRUCK OUT

October 24, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Expert evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

There have been numerous cases in which parties have attempted to give expert evidence in witness statements.  Another example can be seen in the decision in New Media Distribution Company Sezc Ltd v Kagalovsky [2018] EWHC 2742 (Ch). An attempt to…

WITNESS STATEMENTS AND WITNESS EVIDENCE: DO YOU KNOW ABOUT CPR 32.5(4): "LATE EVIDENCE" SHOULD BE HARD TO ADDUCE

WITNESS STATEMENTS AND WITNESS EVIDENCE: DO YOU KNOW ABOUT CPR 32.5(4): “LATE EVIDENCE” SHOULD BE HARD TO ADDUCE

October 23, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Limitation, Members Content, Witness statements

In the judgment today in The Catholic Child Welfare Society (Diocese of Middlesbrough) & Ors v CD [2018] EWCA Civ 2342 the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal against a claimant being successful in a Section 33 application.  There is an…

NEW WITNESS STATEMENTS AND EXPERT EVIDENCE NOT ALLOWED: DENTON APPLIED TO CASE MANAGEMENT: COMPLIANCE WITH DIRECTIONS IS THE ONLY SAFE OPTION

NEW WITNESS STATEMENTS AND EXPERT EVIDENCE NOT ALLOWED: DENTON APPLIED TO CASE MANAGEMENT: COMPLIANCE WITH DIRECTIONS IS THE ONLY SAFE OPTION

October 21, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Expert evidence, Extensions of time, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Witness statements

In SJ Moore (Jeweller) Limited -v- Squibb Group Limited [2018] EWHC 2731 (QB) Denton principles were considered and applied when the defendant wanted to adduce new evidence.  What is notable  here is the fact that the defendant had the expert…

MARMITE: SKELETON ARGUMENTS: "SO CALLED": ATTEMPTS TO APPEAL THE FACTS: A SPREAD OF ISSUES CONSIDERED

MARMITE: SKELETON ARGUMENTS: “SO CALLED”: ATTEMPTS TO APPEAL THE FACTS: A SPREAD OF ISSUES CONSIDERED

October 19, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Members Content, Witness statements

In  Solicitors Regulation Authority v Day & Ors [2018] EWHC 2726 the Divisional Court rejected the SRA’s appeal against a decision of the Solicitors’ Disciplinary Tribunal. There are some interesting comments about the number of documents and the length of skeleton’s…

AGGRESSIVE LITIGATION IS COUNTER-PRODUCTIVE: JUDGE REFUSES DEFENDANT'S APPLICATION TO STRIKE OUT WITNESS STATEMENTS (WITH A COMMENT, OR TWO, AMONG THE WAY)

AGGRESSIVE LITIGATION IS COUNTER-PRODUCTIVE: JUDGE REFUSES DEFENDANT’S APPLICATION TO STRIKE OUT WITNESS STATEMENTS (WITH A COMMENT, OR TWO, AMONG THE WAY)

October 15, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Conduct, Members Content, Witness statements

I am grateful to barrister Adam Heppinstall for sending me a copy of the judgment of Mr Justice Fraser today in Bates -v- The Post Office [2018] EWHC 2968 (QB). This is a forceful judgment and what the judge had…

USING A SKELETON ARGUMENT TO TRY TO FILL GAPS IN THE EVIDENCE  THIS IS NOT GOING TO END WELL...

USING A SKELETON ARGUMENT TO TRY TO FILL GAPS IN THE EVIDENCE THIS IS NOT GOING TO END WELL…

October 12, 2018 · by gexall · in Advocacy, Appeals, Case Management, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements, Written advocacy

The judgment today in M&P Enterprises (London) Ltd v Norfolk Square (Northern Section) Ltd [2018] EWHC 2665 (Ch) makes interesting reading. The appeal concerned criticisms of the conduct of a trial by a circuit judge.  The main difficulty was that the…

WHEN WITNESSES DID NOT ATTEND TRIAL 3: ADVERSE INFERENCES ARE DRAWN IN A CLINICAL NEGLIGENCE CASE

WHEN WITNESSES DID NOT ATTEND TRIAL 3: ADVERSE INFERENCES ARE DRAWN IN A CLINICAL NEGLIGENCE CASE

October 10, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Clinical Negligence, Disclosure, Members Content, Witness statements

There are three cases today about the implications of witnesses not attending trial.  This was an issue in Asante v Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust [2018] EWHC 2570 (QB). The absence of key witnesses from the defendant led…

WHEN WITNESSES DO NOT ATTEND TRIAL 1: WITNESS EVIDENCE NOT ALLOWED: A BROKEN FINGER IS NOT A GOOD EXCUSE NOT TO ATTEND COURT

WHEN WITNESSES DO NOT ATTEND TRIAL 1: WITNESS EVIDENCE NOT ALLOWED: A BROKEN FINGER IS NOT A GOOD EXCUSE NOT TO ATTEND COURT

October 10, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

This is the first of two posts today in relation to witnesses not attending to be cross-examined.  In EC Medica Group UK Ltd & Ors v Dearnley-Davison & Ors [2018] EWHC 1952 (Ch) Kelyn Bacon QC (sitting as a Deputy High…

PROVING THINGS 128: CLAIMANT'S EVIDENCE NOT FULL, CLEAR, FRANK OR UNEQUIVOCAL IN RESPONSE TO APPLICATION FOR SECURITY FOR COSTS

PROVING THINGS 128: CLAIMANT’S EVIDENCE NOT FULL, CLEAR, FRANK OR UNEQUIVOCAL IN RESPONSE TO APPLICATION FOR SECURITY FOR COSTS

October 3, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Costs, Members Content, Security for Costs, Witness statements

In Danilina v Chernukhin & Ors [2018] EWHC 2503 (Comm) Mr Justice Teare was critical of  the quality of the evidence that the respondent adduced in response to an application for security for costs. THE CASE The defendants sought an…

ADVISING YOUR CLIENT ON LITIGATION RISKS 2 & 3 : RISKING IT ALL ON A RECOLLECTION OF A MEETING & THE WITNESS WHO GIVES A WHOLLY NEW ACCOUNT FROM THE WITNESS BOX

ADVISING YOUR CLIENT ON LITIGATION RISKS 2 & 3 : RISKING IT ALL ON A RECOLLECTION OF A MEETING & THE WITNESS WHO GIVES A WHOLLY NEW ACCOUNT FROM THE WITNESS BOX

September 27, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Costs, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment in Slade (t/a Richard Slade And Co) v Abbhi [2018] EWHC 2039 (Comm) (24 September 2018) illustrates another risk of litigation.  The risk of a witness giving a wholly new account whilst giving evidence at trial. THE CASE The…

ADVISING ON LITIGATION RISKS 1: YOU CAN BE BELIEVED AS A WITNESS AND STILL LOSE YOUR CASE

ADVISING ON LITIGATION RISKS 1: YOU CAN BE BELIEVED AS A WITNESS AND STILL LOSE YOUR CASE

September 17, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Risks of litigation, Witness statements

Earlier posts have looked at the concept of “litigation risks”. This is something we are all aware of as practising lawyers. We advise on those risks on a daily basis.  However very little is written about this.  This is the…

BACK TO BASICS 15: CHALLENGING THE AUTHENTICITY OF DOCUMENTS: A PRIMER

BACK TO BASICS 15: CHALLENGING THE AUTHENTICITY OF DOCUMENTS: A PRIMER

September 12, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Disclosure, Members Content, Witness statements

In the 10th post in this series I looked at the importance of serving a notice of non-admittance  of  the authenticity of documents promptly.  Here we look at the basics of the rule. Put bluntly if you do not serve…

PROVING THINGS 127: WRITTEN CONTRACT - WHAT WRITTEN CONTRACT? APPLICATION FOR AN INJUNCTION FAILS WHEN CLAIMANT CANNOT PROVE A CONTRACT WAS EVER SIGNED

PROVING THINGS 127: WRITTEN CONTRACT – WHAT WRITTEN CONTRACT? APPLICATION FOR AN INJUNCTION FAILS WHEN CLAIMANT CANNOT PROVE A CONTRACT WAS EVER SIGNED

September 9, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Injunctions, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment of HHJ Neil Bidder QC in Tenon FM Ltd v Cawley & Ors [2018] EWHC 1972 (QB) shows a failure by a claimant to prove the most basic of issues.  The claimant could not establish that a defendant had…

CIVIL PROCEDURE BACK TO BASICS 13: WHAT IS MEANT BY WITNESS "CREDIBILITY"? WHY THIS IS OFTEN CENTRAL TO A LITIGATOR'S WORK

CIVIL PROCEDURE BACK TO BASICS 13: WHAT IS MEANT BY WITNESS “CREDIBILITY”? WHY THIS IS OFTEN CENTRAL TO A LITIGATOR’S WORK

September 4, 2018 · by gexall · in Avoiding negligence claims, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

Many  civil cases  turn on  witness credibility, yet very little training and education is given to lawyers about assessing credibility.  Every litigator has to be able to make an assessment of this  when taking a case on; before issuing proceedings…

DRAWING ADVERSE INFERENCES WHEN WITNESSES ARE ABSENT: COURT OF APPEAL DECISION TODAY:  COURT HAS A DISCRETION AS TO THE INFERENCES TO BE DRAWN

DRAWING ADVERSE INFERENCES WHEN WITNESSES ARE ABSENT: COURT OF APPEAL DECISION TODAY: COURT HAS A DISCRETION AS TO THE INFERENCES TO BE DRAWN

August 29, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

I am grateful to barrister  Luka Krsljanin for sending me a copy of hte Court of Appeal decision today in Manzi -v- King’s College NHS Foundation Trust [2018] EWCA Civ 1882. The Court rejected an argument that the trial judge…

PROVING THINGS 124: "PUT BLUNTLY: THAT EVIDENCE IS WHOLLY INADEQUATE": DEFENDANT'S EVIDENCE ON AN INJUNCTION APPLICATION

PROVING THINGS 124: “PUT BLUNTLY: THAT EVIDENCE IS WHOLLY INADEQUATE”: DEFENDANT’S EVIDENCE ON AN INJUNCTION APPLICATION

August 29, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Injunctions, Members Content, Witness statements

In Jahangiri v St. George’s University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2018] EWHC 2278 (QB)  Mr Justice Nicklin observed that witness evidence put forward by the defendant was far from adequate. “The Court is best assisted when the evidence of someone who…

THE KIMATHI DECISION 4: THE APPROACH TO WITNESS EVIDENCE: MEMORIES ARE FLUID AND MALLEABLE: SOME KEY POINTS ON GESTMIN

THE KIMATHI DECISION 4: THE APPROACH TO WITNESS EVIDENCE: MEMORIES ARE FLUID AND MALLEABLE: SOME KEY POINTS ON GESTMIN

August 14, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

This is the fourth in the series that looks at the decision in Kimathi & Ors v The Foreign And Commonwealth Office [2018] EWHC 2066 (QB).  The trial judge was looking at evidence of matters that had happened some 50 years earlier,…

THE KIMATHI DECISION 3: THE EVIDENCE GATHERING PROCESS, STANDARD QUESTIONNAIRES AND THE USE OF LEADING QUESTIONS

THE KIMATHI DECISION 3: THE EVIDENCE GATHERING PROCESS, STANDARD QUESTIONNAIRES AND THE USE OF LEADING QUESTIONS

August 8, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

This is the third  in the series that looks at the decision in Kimathi & Ors v The Foreign And Commonwealth Office [2018] EWHC 2066 (QB).  Here we look at the evidence gathering process, in particular the use of questionnaires and the…

CLINICAL NEGLIGENCE, ACCURATE EVIDENCE AND A REMARKABLE CHANGE OF ACCOUNT BY THE CLAIMANT'S WITNESS

CLINICAL NEGLIGENCE, ACCURATE EVIDENCE AND A REMARKABLE CHANGE OF ACCOUNT BY THE CLAIMANT’S WITNESS

August 8, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Clinical Negligence, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment in  Britchford v Staffordshire And Stoke-On-Trent Partnership NHS Trust [2018] EWHC 2109 (QB) is another example of a clinical negligence claim that rested on the accuracy of medical evidence.  A feature of the case is that the claimant did…

THE KIMATHI DECISION 2: TRANSLATORS ON TRIAL: ALSO A LOOK AT THE GUIDANCE ON TRANSLATING WITNESS STATEMENTS

THE KIMATHI DECISION 2: TRANSLATORS ON TRIAL: ALSO A LOOK AT THE GUIDANCE ON TRANSLATING WITNESS STATEMENTS

August 7, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Members Content, Witness statements

This is the second in the series that looks at the decision in Kimathi & Ors v The Foreign And Commonwealth Office [2018] EWHC 2066 (QB).  Here we look at issues relating to the translators.  It shows the way in which the…

CHANGING WITNESS STATEMENTS: COMPARE AND CONTRAST: EDITING STATEMENTS CAN AFFECT CREDIBILITY

CHANGING WITNESS STATEMENTS: COMPARE AND CONTRAST: EDITING STATEMENTS CAN AFFECT CREDIBILITY

July 31, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Clinical Negligence, Members Content, Witness statements

The judgment case of ML (A Child) v Guy’s And St Thomas’ National Healthcare Foundation Trust [2018] EWHC 2010 has an interesting passage on witness statements. It is an example of how early witness statements that were not initially disclosed can…

CIVIL PROCEDURE:BACK TO BASICS 9: THE COURT NOT ENTITLED TO REJECT WRITTEN EVIDENCE UNLESS IT IS "SIMPLY INCREDIBLE"

CIVIL PROCEDURE:BACK TO BASICS 9: THE COURT NOT ENTITLED TO REJECT WRITTEN EVIDENCE UNLESS IT IS “SIMPLY INCREDIBLE”

July 29, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

There is a short passage in Wards Solicitors v Hendawi [2018] EWHC 1907 (Ch) HHJ Paul Matthews (sitting as a judge of the High Court), that serves as a reminder of a basic principle in interlocutory proceedings – a court will not…

PROVING THINGS 119: WITNESSES & EXPERTS : "IN A CASE OF FAIRLY REMARKABLE REPORTS, THIS WAS THE MOST EXTRAORDINARY"

PROVING THINGS 119: WITNESSES & EXPERTS : “IN A CASE OF FAIRLY REMARKABLE REPORTS, THIS WAS THE MOST EXTRAORDINARY”

July 9, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Expert evidence, Experts, Members Content, Witness statements

 If you want to see an example of problematic witness statements, and even more problematic expert witnesses, then read the judgment of Mrs Justice Jefford DBE in Castle Trustee Ltd & Ors v Bombay Palace Restaurant Ltd [2018] EWHC 1602 (TCC). …

ADVOCACY: THE JUDGE'S VIEW SERIES 3 PART 6: MAY IT PLEASE YOU, MADAM: STORIES THAT EVERY LITIGATOR NEEDS TO KNOW...

ADVOCACY: THE JUDGE’S VIEW SERIES 3 PART 6: MAY IT PLEASE YOU, MADAM: STORIES THAT EVERY LITIGATOR NEEDS TO KNOW…

July 7, 2018 · by gexall · in Book Review, Bundles, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

In the sixth in this series we a looking at “May it please you Madam” by retired District Judge Neil Hickman.  This is not designed as a guide for advocates, indeed the subtitle is “A little book of legal whimsy”. …

THE "TRUE VOICE OF THE WITNESSES ARE NOTABLY LACKING FROM THEIR WITNESS STATEMENTS": INORDINATE AMOUNT OF TIME & COSTS SPENT FOR NO GOOD REASON

THE “TRUE VOICE OF THE WITNESSES ARE NOTABLY LACKING FROM THEIR WITNESS STATEMENTS”: INORDINATE AMOUNT OF TIME & COSTS SPENT FOR NO GOOD REASON

July 6, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

In Estera Trust (Jersey) Ltd & Anor v Singh & Ors [2018] EWHC 1715 (Ch) Mr Justice Fancourt made some telling observations about the usefulness of witness statements prepared for the case.  This is a common observation in relation to witness…

PROVING THINGS 117: A DISHONEST POLICE OFFICER IS "MALICIOUS": PROVING A CASE FOR MALICIOUS PROSECUTION AND MISFEASANCE IN PUBLIC OFFICE

PROVING THINGS 117: A DISHONEST POLICE OFFICER IS “MALICIOUS”: PROVING A CASE FOR MALICIOUS PROSECUTION AND MISFEASANCE IN PUBLIC OFFICE

July 5, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

In the judgment in Rees & Ors v Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis [2018] EWCA Civ 1587 the Court of Appeal overturned a finding that a police force was not liable for malicious prosecution and misfeasance in public office because…

HOME SECRETARY REFUSED PERMISSION TO SERVE EVIDENCE LATE: THE OVERRIDING OBJECTIVE WAS USED EVEN IF DENTON DID NOT APPLY

HOME SECRETARY REFUSED PERMISSION TO SERVE EVIDENCE LATE: THE OVERRIDING OBJECTIVE WAS USED EVEN IF DENTON DID NOT APPLY

June 28, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Extensions of time, Members Content, Relief from sanctions, Witness statements

In Teh v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2018] EWHC 1586 (Admin) the Secretary of State was refused permission to rely on evidence served late.  The issue was decided under the Overriding Objective, rather than by reference to the…

PROVING THINGS 116:  HONEST WITNESSES CAN BE WRONG: "INSIGNIFICANT EVENT" BECOMES "MAGNIFIED IN THE CLAIMANT'S MIND"

PROVING THINGS 116: HONEST WITNESSES CAN BE WRONG: “INSIGNIFICANT EVENT” BECOMES “MAGNIFIED IN THE CLAIMANT’S MIND”

June 28, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Personal Injury, Witness statements

The judgment in  Pauline Carter v Kingswood Learning And Leisure Group Limited [2018] EWHC 1616 (QB) shows a scenario where a claimant can be totally honest and credible, but still be wrong. “I am sure she is an honest person, but…

FIFTH BIRTHDAY REVIEW 10: THE PROVING THING SERIES: SIZE DON'T SEEM TO MATTER...

FIFTH BIRTHDAY REVIEW 10: THE PROVING THING SERIES: SIZE DON’T SEEM TO MATTER…

June 27, 2018 · by gexall · in Appeals, Applications, Case Management, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Damages, Experts, Members Content, Witness statements

This is the last in the series looking back at  key series of posts on this blog over the past five years.  Keen observers will note that most series last for about 10 posts. When the “Proving Thing” series started…

FIFTH BIRTHDAY REVIEW 7: THE "BACK TO BASICS" SERIES

FIFTH BIRTHDAY REVIEW 7: THE “BACK TO BASICS” SERIES

June 26, 2018 · by gexall · in Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

I am looking back at the posts that have been part of a series over the past five years. The “Back to Basics” posts are part of  a series that is  very much ongoing. The aim of each post is…

MORE ABOUT WITNESS STATEMENTS AND THE ICI CASE: WHEN EVIDENCE IS NOT ADMISSIBLE AND (WHEN IT IS) IT IS NOT RELIABLE

MORE ABOUT WITNESS STATEMENTS AND THE ICI CASE: WHEN EVIDENCE IS NOT ADMISSIBLE AND (WHEN IT IS) IT IS NOT RELIABLE

June 25, 2018 · by gexall · in Civil evidence, Members Content, Witness statements

We are looking again at aspects of the judgment of Mr Justice Fraser in  Imperial Chemical Industries Ltd v Merit Merrell Technology Ltd [2018] EWHC 1577 (TCC).The previous post in this case looked at the “duplicate” witness statements of the defendant.  Here…

FIFTH BIRTHDAY REVIEW 5: THE JUDGE'S GUIDE TO ADVOCACY SERIES: TWO AND A HALF DONE

FIFTH BIRTHDAY REVIEW 5: THE JUDGE’S GUIDE TO ADVOCACY SERIES: TWO AND A HALF DONE

June 25, 2018 · by gexall · in Advocacy, Applications, Civil evidence, Civil Procedure, Members Content, Witness statements

There are two completed series on judge’s guide to advocacy – and we are part way through the third. There is still plenty of material available and I wouldn’t be surprised if there is a fourth series.  Advice has been…

← Previous 1 … 14 15 16 … 26 Next →

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Subscription notifies you of a new post, it does not give you access to members' content.

Join 12.4K other subscribers

Recent Posts

  • LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 5: DEFENDING A CLAIM BASED ON A COUNTERFACTUAL — 10 KEY POINTS FOR DEFENDANTS
  • LITIGATOR’S LIFELINES 4 : PLEADING AND PROVING THE COUNTERFACTUAL: 10 KEY POINTS FOR CLAIMANTS
  • WITNESS EVIDENCE WEDNESDAY: RECOLLECTION OF MEETINGS TWO YEARS EARLIER IS LIKELY TO BE IMPERFECT: THE FACT THAT THE CLAIMANT’S WITNESSES “SETTLED ON A CONCLUSION THAT EXACTLY ACCORDS WITH THE CLAIMANT’S COMMERCIAL INTERESTS IS UNSURPRISING” BUT NEEDS TO BE “TREATED WITH CAUTION”
  • PROVING THINGS 307: FAILING TO PROVE THE COUNTERFACTUAL: THE CLAIMANTS ESTABLISHED NEGLIGENCE BUT FAILED TO PROVE WHAT THEY WOULD HAVE DONE IF GIVEN THE CORRECT ADVICE
  • ENFORCEMENT BULLETIN No. 8: THE BANK GETS ITS CARS BACK: SUMMARY JUDGMENT, UNDISCLOSED COMMISSIONS AND THE IMPORTANCE OF PLEADING A DEFENCE THAT CAN ACTUALLY DEFEAT THE CLAIM

Top Posts

COSTS BITES 459: A SUCCESSFUL CLAIMANT SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN DEPRIVED OF THEIR COSTS BECAUSE PRECEDENT U WAS SERVED FIVE HOURS LATE
A PRACTICAL AI PRIMER FOR LAWYERS: THE SECOND EDITION OF "ANDREW AND THE MARVELLOUS ANALYTICAL ENGINE": MAJOR ADDITIONS TO A FAST MOVING AND IMPORTANT AREA
COST BITES 459: YOU CAN SPEND £1 MILLION ON COSTS, ESSENTIALLY "WIN" THE CASE BUT STILL NOT RECOVER THE COSTS: HIGH COURT CONSIDERS APPEAL IN A VERY EXPENSIVE BOUNDARY DISPUTE
COSTS BITES 461: THE £14,113 BILL THAT BECAME A £58,543 DEBT (PLUS INTEREST...): COSTS WERE HIGH "IN LARGE PART, THAT APPEARS TO BE AS A RESULT OF THE EXTRA WORK REQUIRED TO ADDRESS THE DEFENDANT'S UNMERITORIOUS AND WIDE-RANGING SUBMISSIONS"
PROVING THINGS 307: FAILING TO PROVE THE COUNTERFACTUAL: THE CLAIMANTS ESTABLISHED NEGLIGENCE BUT FAILED TO PROVE WHAT THEY WOULD HAVE DONE IF GIVEN THE CORRECT ADVICE

Archives

Blogroll

  • Fatal Accident Law
  • Legal Futures
  • Personal injury: Liability and Damages

Books

  • Munkman & Exall on Damages for Personal Injuries and Death 15th ed
  • The APIL Guide to Fatal Accidents 4th edition

Useful Links

  • Buntools (for preparing PDF Bundles)
  • Kings Chambers
  • Kings Chambers Costs & Litigation Funding
  • Kings Chambers Serious Injury
  • The Civil Procedure Rules
  • The Law Society Gazette
  • The National Archives Recently Published Judgments
  • The Senior Court Costs Office Guide 2025
  • www.Bailii.org

Copyright

© Gordon Exall, Exall Legal Training, Civil Litigation Brief, 2013-2026. Unauthorised use and or duplication of the material contained on this blog without permission is strictly prohibited.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.

To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Membership Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertising Policy
  • Copyright
  • Legal Disclaimer

Copyright © 2026 Civil Litigation Brief ®

Powered by Big Yellow Workshop

Loading Comments...

You must be logged in to post a comment.